Seemor
Old Chicago Pizza RestaurantB+Worth Trying
41 Petaluma Blvd N, Petaluma, CA 94952
· Pizza restaurant, Bar, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (1190 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout
Destination for hearty Chicago-style deep dish in a historic upstairs space; expect excellent pies, lively vibes, long waits, and prices above chain pizza.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Old Chicago Pizza exemplifies what makes a neighborhood institution work: strong food quality with hearty deep dish that keeps regulars returning for decades, paired with distinctive historic charm in a brick-lined upstairs room. However, inconsistent execution and notably slow service prevent a higher grade, while long waits and occasional order mishaps reflect operational constraints that limit the experience despite genuine quality at the core.
Restaurant Summary
Up a flight of stairs in a brick-lined landmark, the room feels warm and bustling with views over downtown. Regulars talk about coming here since the late 70s, and one summed it up: "One slice and I was set for the night." It is lively enough that waits happen and it can get pretty noisy during peak hours. The cooking favors classic Chicago deep dish over trends: hearty, generously topped pies with a yeasty crust and bright, tangy sauce. Thin and double crusts are on deck too, plus simple salads and garlicky breads. Expect a longer bake and shareable portions; prices sit above chains but align with the quality and size. Families fit right in. Mini pizzas, plain cheese or pepperoni, Caesar or dinner salads, and warm cookies make it easy for kids, while a gluten-free small thin option helps with basic dietary needs. No kids menu needed when one slice fills a plate.
At a Glance
- Deep dish execution draws loyal regulars and visitors
- Historic upstairs setting with character
- Long waits for pies and occasional order mishaps
- Noise levels high at peak times
- Prices higher than chains but portions offset cost
What Sets It Apart
- historic_upstairs_location
- true_chicago_style_deep_dish
- generous_portions
What People Love
- Hearty slices that satisfy
- Old-school brick ambiance
- Friendly, upbeat servers on good nights
- Pesto garlic bread that steals the show
Points of Concern
- Bake and ticket times can push past 45 minutes during busy periods
- Service inconsistency: a few reports of curt responses or missed orders
- Some diners find the sauce mild or crust overly yeasty on off nights
- Review patterns show balanced authenticity with minimal manipulation risk
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-$45 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Value play: Share a medium deep dish with two toppings ($31-$33) and a large salad ($11-$14)
- Gluten-free diners: choose small thin crust with +$4 upcharge
- Sweet finish: Flourless Chocolate Torte ($8.50) if avoiding gluten
Perfect For
- Craving classic Chicago-style deep dish
- Casual date before a show at the Mystic
- Group dinners where sharing works best
- Family nights with hearty portions
Location Insights
Area: Historic downtown hub with brick buildings, theaters, and casual nightlife; draws locals and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, steady foot traffic; typical downtown caution at night.
Nearby: Adjacent to Mystic Theatre and shops; upstairs in Lanmart Building with views over Petaluma Blvd.
Downtown PetalumaThe dining scene in Downtown Petaluma is diverse, featuring casual eateries, family-friendly restaurants, and artisanal food spots. The atmosphere is welcoming and community-oriented, with a focus on local ingredients and a relaxed pace.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–21:00
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday11:30–21:00
Friday11:30–21:00
Saturday11:30–21:00
Sunday11:30–21:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →