Seemor
Monterey › Monterey › Monterey's Fish House
Monterey's Fish HouseB+Worth Trying
2114 Del Monte Ave, Monterey, CA 93940
· Seafood restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (2877 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout
Bustling local-favorite seafood spot with oak-grilled oysters, big portions, and long waits; quality is often great but inconsistencies and occasional food safety complaints mean choose carefully and book ahead.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Monterey's Fish House delivers strong food quality with standout oak-grilled oysters and tender calamari that justify its loyal following, supported by attentive, friendly service. However, inconsistent execution—ranging from stellar meals to bland chowder and occasional overcooking—prevents a higher grade, and multiple food safety reports tied to raw seafood create legitimate reliability concerns that outweigh the generous portions and fair value.
Restaurant Summary
From the outside it looks unassuming, but inside it is cozy and bustling with servers hustling plates of seafood and pasta. Diners talk about friendly, hard-working staff and big bowls of cioppino. One guest gushed, "Calamari steak was unbelievably tender." Expect a crowd and long waits without reservations, though bar seats can be a find. The cooking skews classic Italian-American seafood rather than experimental—think oak-grilled oysters, snapper, salmon, and hearty pastas. The style is comforting and ingredient-focused, with wood smoke as a signature note. When the kitchen is on, flavors sing and portions satisfy; on off nights, some report bland chowder or overcooked fish, so lean into greatest hits and nightly specials. Family-wise, it works: there is a burger, fried calamari, simple grilled fish, and marinara pasta that most kids will eat. Just know there is no formal kids menu and waits can be tough for little ones. Ask to swap pasta for vegetables if needed and aim for lunch or early dinner to minimize the queue.
At a Glance
- Oak-grilled oysters and tender calamari steak are house standouts
- Generous portions offer solid value for Monterey
- Wait estimates can be unreliable; reservations strongly advised
- Mixed feedback on chowder and occasional overcooking
- Multiple illness reports tied to raw oysters/scallops across dates
What Sets It Apart
- oak_grilled_oysters_over_wood
- hearty_cioppino_bowls
- locals_and_visitors_mix
What People Love
- Smoky oak-grilled flavor on oysters and fish
- Hearty, loaded seafood pastas
- Friendly, hustling staff energy
- Feeling like a local find off the tourist strip
Points of Concern
- Long, poorly estimated waits at peak; some walk-outs reported
- Inconsistent dishes: watery chowder or dry fish on off nights
- Several independent reports of GI illness after raw oysters or scallops
- Noise can be intense in the small dining room
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$48-66 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Choose oak-grilled preparations (snapper, salmon, swordfish) for best flavor-to-price balance
- Swap pasta sides for extra vegetables if you prefer lighter plates
- Pick one indulgent starter (grilled oysters or fried calamari) and share to manage cost and portions
Perfect For
- Seafood night with friends
- Casual date after the Aquarium
- Solo bite at the bar
- Family dinner if you book early
Location Insights
Area: Low-rise, working-class/commercial strip a short drive from tourist core; locals mix with visitors seeking value off Cannery Row.
Safety: Generally safe with steady car traffic; queues may form outdoors, exposed to weather and roadside.
Nearby: Near Highway 1 corridor; short drive to downtown, Cannery Row, and Monterey Bay Aquarium; convenient parking nearby.
MontereyMonterey is a historic coastal city with a strong maritime heritage, popular for its aquarium, Cannery Row, and waterfront dining. The dining scene heavily features fresh seafood and casual to mid-range restaurants catering to visitors and locals alike, with a relaxed and family-friendly atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Tuesday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Wednesday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Thursday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Friday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Saturday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Sunday11:30–14:00, 17:00–20:30
Available: Reservations, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →