Seemor

The FishmarketB+Worth Trying

Name: The Fishmarket
Address: Harbour, 23A Pier Pl, Newhaven, Edinburgh EH6 4LP, Edinburgh, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.4

Harbour, 23A Pier Pl, Newhaven, Edinburgh EH6 4LP · Seafood restaurant · 4.4/5 Google (4455 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Destination-worthy Scottish seafood with standout fish and chips and harbour views; book for dine-in or use the popular takeaway, but expect premium pricing and occasional service rigidity.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

The Fishmarket delivers solid neighborhood dining through exceptional seafood quality and outstanding harbour views, but inconsistent execution and operational constraints prevent a higher grade. Fresh fish and friendly service are reliable strengths, though the small dining room and variable takeaway wait times create friction that keeps this from competing with the area's premier seafood destinations.

Restaurant Summary

Right on Newhaven Harbour, The Fishmarket pairs crisp-battered classics with a breezy waterfront setting and an always-busy takeaway. Guests rave about the haddock, oysters, and chowder: "Fresh fish, light batter, generous portions." Book ahead—the dining room is small but lively, and queues are common when the weather is good. The kitchen leans elevated traditional rather than showy fusion; think Scottish seafood done right with the odd twist like monkfish curry or chorizo-baked scallops. If you want premium shellfish, they have it—just know pricing reflects the quality of ingredients. For the full experience, plan a reservation; otherwise, the takeaway delivers the same fresh-cooked fish if you can handle a wait at peak times. Families do well here thanks to familiar favorites: battered haddock, scampi, burgers, chips, and simple sides. There is no stated kids menu, but portions satisfy most appetites. Be aware that sauces cost extra and allergy handling at the takeaway drew mixed feedback; cautious families may prefer dine-in for clearer guidance.

At a Glance

Exceptionally fresh fish with standout batter and harbour views
Takeaway option for casual waterfront eating
Reservations essential for dine-in; small dining room
Takeaway waits and occasional portion inconsistency
Sauces and service charge can add up

What Sets It Apart

waterfront_setting
dual_model_dine_in_plus_takeaway
Scottish_shellfish_focus

What People Love

Harbour views at sunset
Ultra-crisp batter and flaky haddock
Rich smoked haddock chowder
Friendly servers who squeeze in walk-ins
Oysters that taste straight from the sea

Points of Concern

Rigid host-stand behavior reported by a minority, especially around reservations and seating
Peak-time takeaway waits of 30-45 minutes are common
Portion size inconsistency reported occasionally (thin fish or overcooked squid)
Allergy handling at takeaway counter reported as limited

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleHybrid Average Cost£38-58 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For first-timers: Chowder + Standard Haddock (£8 + £17-19)
Shellfish fans: Scallops or Langoustines (£28-35)
Budget-friendly: From the Fryer haddock (£15) with chips (£5) and mushy peas (£1.50)

Perfect For

A seafood-focused evening by the water
Out-of-town visitors seeking a destination fish and chips
Families who want familiar seafood favorites
Casual date with a harbour stroll

Location Insights

Area: Waterfront pier in Newhaven near Leith; scenic, relaxed, draws locals and visitors.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked waterfront with good lighting and footfall.

Nearby: Harbour promenade, nearby restaurants, Ocean Terminal area, tram access within walking distance.

NewhavenNewhaven is a historic fishing village turned residential area with a relaxed, community-oriented atmosphere. The dining scene here features a mix of traditional seafood spots and contemporary eateries, often frequented by locals and visitors seeking fresh, locally sourced food in a scenic harbor setting.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:00–21:15 Tuesday11:00–21:15 Wednesday11:00–21:15 Thursday11:00–21:15 Friday11:00–21:15 Saturday11:00–21:15 Sunday11:00–21:15

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →