Lively UWS taqueria with standout tacos, strong margaritas, and friendly, fast service; pricing and portions polarize, with burritos called small by some.
Taqueria 86 delivers solid neighborhood taqueria performance with excellent taco execution—birria, al pastor, and fish tacos earn consistent praise—and attentive, fast service that keeps the casual vibe moving. However, consistency dips with delivery burritos and portion concerns, and the comfortable but modest setting lacks destination appeal, preventing a higher grade. A reliable Upper West Side favorite that excels at its core taqueria mission.
One caveat: Pricing is genuinely expensive ($16-21 for three tacos; $11-16 appetizers) which may surprise casual diners