Seemor
Alfie's Pizzeria & RestaurantB-Worth Trying
86-08 117th St, Richmond Hill, NY 11418
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· 4.7/5 Google (947 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Neighborhood pizzeria with beloved Sicilian and upside-down pies, friendly family-run vibe, budget pricing, but quality can be inconsistent and it is cash only.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Alfie's Pizzeria delivers solid neighborhood appeal through strong food quality on signature items and warm, attentive service, earning genuine customer loyalty across decades. However, inconsistent execution—undercooked or bland pies, especially on delivery— and isolated safety concerns prevent a higher grade. Budget pricing and family-friendly atmosphere make it worth visiting for the Sicilian pie, but expect variable results.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels like a classic Queens slice shop: warm and bustling with TVs, kids, and regulars swapping stories at the counter. Staff energy reads genuinely kind, and one guest noted, "the counter team made us feel like neighbors." However, expect cash only and the occasional peak-hour crunch. The cooking leans New York traditional rather than chefly theatrics. Fans rave about the Sicilian and the upside-down pie, where the fresh-leaning sauce and crisped edges shine. On off days, a few diners found pies underdone or a bit bland—delivery timing seems to magnify that—so the best experiences tend to be hot slices right from the counter. Families fit right in here. Simple classics—plain slices, grandma pie, baked ziti, zeppole—make it easy for kids, and staff are warm with little ones. There is no kids menu, but the familiar pizza-and-pasta lineup covers most tastes at budget-friendly prices.
At a Glance
- Beloved Sicilian and upside-down pies draw loyal regulars
- Budget pricing with large portions
- Quality inconsistency—reports of undercooked or bland pies, especially via delivery
- Cash only; on-site ATM fee mentioned
- Delivery service complaints include rudeness and wrong/delayed orders in some cases
What Sets It Apart
- beloved_sicilian_square
- family_run_legacy
- budget_slices_and_pies
What People Love
- Nostalgic neighborhood vibe
- Sicilian and upside-down slices with fresh-tasting sauce
- Friendly, jokey counter service
- Big pies that feed a crowd
Points of Concern
- Quality can swing from excellent to undercooked or burnt depending on timing and order channel
- Delivery issues: wrong addresses, delays, rude drivers reported by a minority
- Cash only policy with ATM fee surprises some guests
- Review patterns are mostly organic but include a few generic superlatives without detail
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$14-$24 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Order a Sicilian or upside-down pie and request well-done for extra structure
- Pair with a garden or Greek salad for balance at $5.50-$6.00
- For value: personal pie at $7.75 or a baked special around $9-$10
Perfect For
- Grabbing a hot slice at the counter
- Affordable family pizza night
- Neighborhood comfort-food cravings
- Out-of-towners seeking a local Queens slice shop
Location Insights
Area: Residential Queens block with local foot traffic; neighborhood staple drawing families and longtime residents.
Safety: Generally safe, everyday neighborhood dynamics; occasional crowding from kids mentioned in reviews.
Nearby: Near homes, small shops, and other casual eateries; convenience for takeout and delivery.
Richmond HillRichmond Hill is a residential neighborhood with a strong community feel, known for its authentic South Asian and Caribbean eateries alongside traditional American dining options. The dining scene is casual and family-oriented, reflecting the multicultural makeup of the area.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–21:00
Tuesday12:00–21:00
Wednesday12:00–21:00
Thursday12:00–21:00
Friday12:00–21:00
Saturday12:00–21:00
Sunday12:00–21:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →