Seemor
Charleston › Charleston › Circa 1886 Restaurant
Circa 1886 RestaurantA-Worth Trying
149 Wentworth St, Charleston, SC 29401
· Fine dining restaurant, American restaurant, Bar
· 4.8/5 Google (976 reviews)
Reservations
Elegant, creative tasting-menu destination inside Wentworth Mansion with standout service and wine; food wows many but some report inconsistency and slow pacing at a premium price.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Circa 1886 delivers expert sommelier guidance and attentive, personalized service within an elegant historic mansion setting that justifies its special-occasion positioning. However, inconsistent seasoning and temperature execution across visits, combined with extended pacing between courses, prevents the grade A territory that its refined ambiance and service expertise might otherwise suggest. The tasting menu format delivers memorable moments but lacks the reliability expected at this price point.
Restaurant Summary
Set within the carriage house of Wentworth Mansion, Circa 1886 feels romantic and refined. Servers and the sommelier move with calm precision, and guests often gush that the opening amuse sets the tone. However, there are some review authenticity concerns - some review patterns are consistent with solicited or influenced feedback. Still, many diners describe service as warm and polished, with managers checking on tables and guiding pacing. The cooking leans modern and creative rather than classic Lowcountry, with influences like sumac and berbere alongside premium ingredients. Two distinct tasting menus (Ashley and Cooper) showcase elegant plating, thoughtful textures, and wine pairings that elevate the experience. Most nights deliver a memorable journey, though a minority report uneven seasoning or slow pacing at this price point. Families should know this is a formal, course-driven spot with limited child-friendly dishes. While a la carte options exist, the emphasis is on tasting menus and wine pairings. Based on the current menu, kids might prefer simpler fare elsewhere; for special occasions with teens who enjoy adventurous food, reserve early and request a quiet table away from the bar.
At a Glance
- Elegant, historic setting inside Wentworth Mansion
- Two tasting menus with expert wine pairings
- Pacing can be slow and some courses under-seasoned
- Formal vibe and limited flexibility on tasting menus
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- two_distinct_tasting_menus
- historic_mansion_setting
- sommelier_pairings
What People Love
- Romantic carriage house ambiance
- Sommelier guidance that enhances each course
- Memorable amuse-bouche and desserts
- Attentive servers who personalize the evening
- Option to choose between two tasting paths
Points of Concern
- Pricing is genuinely expensive ($43-52 mains; $135 tasting; $225 with pairings), which may surprise casual diners
- Reports of uneven seasoning and temperature on some courses
- Tasting menus have limited modification options; pacing can stretch beyond 2 hours
- Formal setting is not ideal for young children or device use
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$105-145 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For pescatarians, consider the Catch of the Day ($44) or Sumac Roasted Swordfish ($43)
- Gluten-free diners have several marked options including Beef Tenderloin and fish entrees
- Choose tasting menu on first visit; return a la carte for focus on a favorite protein
Perfect For
- Anniversary dinners with wine pairings
- Travelers seeking a refined tasting-menu experience
- Celebrations where polished service matters
- Food lovers who enjoy contemporary techniques
Location Insights
Area: Historic district setting tied to Wentworth Mansion; upscale, romantic, special-occasion oriented.
Safety: Well-trafficked historic area with good lighting; generally safe for evening dining.
Nearby: Near historic homes, boutique inns, and downtown attractions; walkable to King St.
Charleston Historic DistrictThe Charleston Historic District offers a charming and elegant dining atmosphere with a strong emphasis on Southern cuisine and hospitality. It attracts visitors seeking authentic Lowcountry flavors in refined settings, often blending historic ambiance with modern culinary innovation.
South of BroadSouth of Broad is a prestigious micro-neighborhood known for its grand historic homes and proximity to waterfront views. It hosts some of Charleston's finest dining establishments, offering an intimate and upscale experience.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday17:00–21:00
Tuesday17:00–21:00
Wednesday
Thursday17:00–21:00
Friday17:00–21:00
Saturday17:00–21:00
Sunday
Available: Reservations
View full analysis on Seemor →