Seemor
Phil's PizzaBWorth Trying
1102 W 35th St, Chicago, IL 60609, United States
· Pizza restaurant, Delivery Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (2261 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Classic South Side tavern-style pies with generous sausage and crisp-chewy crust; great pizza value but frequent complaints about burnt pies, order errors, and brusque counter service.
Why it gets a B for overall quality
Phil's Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza with strong core execution—generous sausage, balanced sauce, and crisp-chewy crust—and good value that keeps regulars coming back for decades. However, quality varies noticeably, with burnt pies and order mistakes during peak times, and counter service often feels curt rather than welcoming. It's a classic South Side staple worth visiting for authentic tavern-cut pizza, but inconsistency prevents it from competing with the area's most reliable dining destinations.
Restaurant Summary
A true Bridgeport staple where the pies come square-cut and loaded. The room is simple and often bustling with takeout traffic; service is brisk and can feel brusque. One fan put it simply: "The sausage is generous and the crust snaps just right." Expect a no-frills pickup flow and big neighborhood energy. The kitchen leans classic tavern-style, not trendy—more comfort than creativity. Think sturdy crust with a bit of chew, balanced sauce, and that signature South Side sausage. When they hit their stride, it is exactly what locals crave; on slammed nights, results can vary, with some reports of overdone pies or order mix-ups. Families are well served here: kids can crush a plain cheese or sausage pie, and sides like fries and mozzarella sticks are easy wins. There is no kids menu per se, but the core pizza-and-sides lineup fits most young eaters. Dine-in is basic; many families prefer pickup for a smoother experience.
At a Glance
- Classic South Side tavern-cut with hearty sausage and crisp-chewy crust
- Good value for medium two-topping pies; leftovers common
- Recurring reports of burnt pies and order errors during rush
- Counter service often described as curt or rude
- Peak events bring extreme waits and phone issues
What Sets It Apart
- house_sausage_topping_heft
- true_south_side_tavern_style
- regulars_known_by_staff
What People Love
- Generous, well-seasoned sausage
- Crisp edges with some chew
- Classic Chicago square-cut style
- Reheats surprisingly well
- Solid value on medium two-topping
Points of Concern
- Burnt or undercooked pies reported by multiple customers, especially during peak rushes
- Order accuracy issues: wrong size, wrong toppings, meat added to veggie orders
- Counter and phone service often described as impatient or rude
- Phones unanswered or disconnected during very busy times; long lines on event nights
- Review patterns show authentic mix; concerns reflect operations, not manipulation
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$22-36 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Lean into classic sausage-focused pies for best results
- Ask for pepperoni on top if you prefer curl and crisp
- Vegetarians: verify no sausage added by mistake before leaving
Perfect For
- Game-night takeout with friends
- Casual family pizza night
- South Side tavern-style fans
- Locals craving heavy-topped sausage pies
Location Insights
Area: Residential South Side hub with working-class roots and sports traffic from nearby stadium; strong neighborhood following.
Safety: Generally active and fine along main corridors; standard urban caution at late hours.
Nearby: Close to homes, small businesses, and police precinct activity; many customers pick up to-go.
BridgeportBridgeport offers a diverse dining environment featuring classic Chicago fare, ethnic cuisines, and trendy new restaurants. The social atmosphere is community-oriented and welcoming, with a blend of old-school charm and modern influences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–23:00
Tuesday16:00–23:00
Wednesday16:00–23:00
Thursday16:00–23:00
Friday16:00–00:00
Saturday16:00–00:00
Sunday16:00–23:00
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →