Destination for New Haven style pies with house-brewed beer; great flavors and lively vibe, but occasional service lapses and order accuracy issues surface during rushes.
Piece Pizzeria and Brewery delivers exceptional food quality with distinctive New Haven-style pies and flavorful execution that draws loyal crowds and destination appeal. However, inconsistent execution during rushes—grease levels, slice evenness, occasional soggy pies—prevents a higher grade, as does moderate food safety concerns from isolated incidents. The brewpub excels as a social gathering spot with strong beer pairings and appealing Wicker Park location, making it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants despite execution variability.
One caveat: Execution inconsistency: occasional greasy or floppy pies and uneven slice cuts