Beloved Lakeview corner bar serving standout tavern-style pizza, friendly service, and cheap drinks; cash only and occasional service delays at peak times.
Side Street Saloon earns its A- grade through exceptional tavern-style pizza and consistently friendly, attentive bartender service that define its neighborhood character. Strong consistency and deep local loyalty reinforce its standing as a Chicago staple, though occasional service delays at peak times and modest design appeal prevent it from reaching grade A standards. Fair pricing and welcoming atmosphere make it competitive with the area's better neighborhood establishments.
The setting is a Lakeview corner tavern with warm neighborhood energy, vintage touches, and sports on TV. Bartenders are often friendly and attentive, and the room hums without shouting. As one fan put it, "I think about this pizza day and night." The cooking leans classic Chicago: tavern-style thin crust with a cracker snap, well-fried cheese curds, and straightforward bar snacks. No gimmicks, just well-executed comfort backed by reasonably priced drinks. Expect simple toppings, balanced sauce, and pies that reheat beautifully. For families, it is casual and kid-friendly by menu—pizza, fries, and curds are easy wins. There is no kids menu noted, and it is cash only with an ATM inside. Space can be tight during games, so earlier visits work best with little ones.
Area vibe: Residential Lakeview side street near Lincoln Ave; relaxed neighborhood vibe with locals and pre/post-show crowds.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked neighborhood; typical city awareness at night.
What's nearby: Near Athenaeum Center, tree-lined blocks, other bars and eateries on Lincoln/Belmont.
It is cash only with an on-site ATM, tables fill up on game nights, and service can lag during peaks.
Think classic Chicago tavern energy with jukebox, pool table and a lively but conversational atmosphere on game nights.