Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating
Creative Chicago-and-NY-style pizza spot with mixed execution: enthusiastic fans, but many report bland flavors, long waits, and add-on charges; choose carefully and manage expectations.
Homeslice Pizza delivers playful, shareable deep-dish pies with creative toppings and a team willing to remake mistakes, but inconsistent execution—ranging from praised crunchy crusts to complaints of bland cheese and sparse sauce—undermines reliability. Long waits of 40–60 minutes and isolated food safety reports further limit appeal, while premium pricing amplifies frustration when quality falters. Worth a visit for adventurous pizza lovers, but expect uneven results.
In Del Valle, this spot riffs on Chicago pies and NY nostalgia in a casual room that some find warm but simple. Service often comes off friendly, and on good nights they will remake a pie without fuss. Still, expect patience: several diners mention 40–60 minute bakes, and a few felt nickel-and-dimed on extras. One guest summed it up: "Big pie, big wait, and flavors that did not always land." The cooking leans hearty and playful rather than fancy—think deep dish built to share, a spicy-sweet hot honey pie, and even an al pastor-inspired pizza. When it clicks, people praise the crunchy crust and balance; when it misses, critiques target bland cheese and sparse sauce. Portions are generous, pricing is premium for the area, and the team engages when things go wrong, but execution can be uneven. For families, the basics travel well: pepperoni, mozzarella sticks, simple pastas, and desserts like lava cake will suit kids. There is no stated kids menu, but pizzas (MXN170–197) and sides (around MXN150) are friendly to sharing. Be aware of possible packaging or extras fees, and skip the spicier or fusion toppings for picky eaters.
Area: Leafy residential Del Valle with mixed commercial strips; popular with families and young professionals.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, steady foot traffic; typical urban caution at night.
Nearby: Near parks, cafes, bakeries, everyday retail and offices; destination for casual dining.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →