Seemor
Old Mates PubB-?Proceed Cautiously
170 John St, New York, NY 10038
· Pub, Australian restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (405 reviews)
Reservations · Outdoor seating
Lively Australian-themed pub with standout burgers, schnitzels, and trivia nights; great vibes but can be loud, crowded, and pricey with inconsistent service and tipping friction.
Why it gets a B-? for overall quality
⚠️ Review concerns: This assessment reflects moderate uncertainty due to questionable review patterns. See details in Authenticity Assessment. Old Mates Pub delivers solid pub fare with standout items like its top-tier cheeseburger and crisp fish and chips, supported by a vibrant multi-level setting that excels for group gatherings. However, quality variation across visits—from undercooked sausages to inconsistent sauces—and uneven service during peak times prevent higher marks. The lively sports-bar energy and loyal following make it worth visiting for casual dining, though pricier-than-typical pub costs and crowding on weekends temper the overall appeal.
Restaurant Summary
The scene is a big, multi-level hangout where the first floor glows with sunlight and the basement turns into a party. Expect lively sports energy, long lines on weekends, and staff who try to keep the chaos fun. A guest summed it up as "great for a casual catch-up, but it can feel like a nightclub at peak." However, there are some review authenticity concerns suggesting certain reviews may be solicited or influenced. The cooking leans pub-comfort with a few refined touches: a top-tier cheeseburger, crisp fish and chips with chicken salt, and an unexpectedly polished seafood linguine. Schnitzels and parmas satisfy most, though some argue over authenticity and sauce thickness. Drinks skew Aussie-adjacent with occasional shortages; overall it feels like elevated comfort food rather than a purist shrine. Families can make this work, especially earlier in the day. There is no dedicated kids menu reported, but kid-friendly staples like burgers, schnitzel, and chips usually land well. Noise and crowds rise fast on weekends, so aim for weekday lunches or early evenings if you need calmer seating.
At a Glance
- Cheeseburger consistently praised as a city standout
- Fun multi-level vibe with trivia and DJs
- Pricey for pub fare; some checks feel high
- Inconsistent service and tipping disputes at busy times
- Door lines and crowding on weekends
What Sets It Apart
- authentic_aussie_vibe_details
- multi_level_event_flexibility
- trivia_culture_with_dj_nights
What People Love
- The burger delivers serious satisfaction
- Authentic-feeling Aussie memorabilia and vibe
- Trivia and DJ nights keep it lively
- Cold beers and chicken salt fries win fans
Points of Concern
- Pricing is high for pub fare; expect $25-$39 mains and $14-$16 desserts
- Service swings from warm to indifferent, especially at the downstairs bar
- Weekend lines and door policy cause frustration; not ideal for quick entry
- Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (high five-star share and polarized tone) which may not reflect typical diner experience
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleHybrid
Average Cost$44-$66 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair cheeseburger with Porterhouse Chips ($10) and finish with Milo Sundae ($16)
- Vegetarians: Eggplant Parma ($24) plus Garden Salad ($12)
- Seafood fans: Natural Oysters (marketed at $24 half-dozen) then Seafood Linguine ($28)
Perfect For
- After-work beers and a great burger
- Trivia night with friends
- Casual date that turns lively later
- Homesick Aussies craving pub classics
Location Insights
Area: Historic Seaport/FiDi edge: after-work crowd, tourists, and weekend nightlife energy.
Safety: Generally safe with high foot traffic; occasional crowd-control complaints at door.
Nearby: Near South Street Seaport, waterfront promenades, offices, tourist attractions; multiple bars nearby.
Financial DistrictThe dining scene in the Financial District is diverse, ranging from quick-service eateries catering to office workers and tourists to upscale restaurants and trendy bars. The area has seen a rise in residential living, which has brought more casual and neighborhood-focused dining options alongside traditional business lunch spots. The atmosphere is a blend of bustling daytime activity and quieter evenings with a community feel.
South Street SeaportSouth Street Seaport is a historic waterfront area within the Financial District known for its maritime heritage, shopping, and dining. It attracts tourists and locals alike with its scenic views, seafood restaurants, and casual dining venues, offering a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere distinct from the more corporate core of the Financial District.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–01:00
Tuesday16:00–01:00
Wednesday16:00–01:00
Thursday12:00–01:00
Friday12:00–02:00
Saturday12:00–02:00
Sunday12:00–23:00
Available: Reservations, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →