Seemor
Serpico's RestaurantB+Worth Trying
7 Aewa Pl, Makawao, HI 96768
· Italian restaurant, Pizza restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (734 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout
Reliable, generous-portioned Italian-American and New York-style pizza near Haleakala; great for hearty meals, with occasional service and consistency hiccups.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Serpico's delivers reliable comfort dining with strong food quality anchored by crisp New York-style pizza and generous portions, plus genuinely welcoming service that makes the experience feel personal. Occasional consistency lapses—dry crust, cold takeout, missing items—and a simple, modest dining room prevent it from reaching higher territory, though it remains a solid neighborhood favorite and convenient Haleakala-area stop worth visiting.
Restaurant Summary
This upcountry spot feels like a small-town slice shop with warm, easygoing service and the kind of generous plates that make road-trippers smile. One diner summed it up: "Crisp-thin pies, hearty portions, and a cozy, unfussy room." It is the handy stop many make before or after Haleakala, with staff that often comes across as genuinely welcoming. The cooking leans classic Italian-American—New York-style pizza, creamy pastas, and crowd-pleasing starters—punctuated by Maui touches like the Kalua Pork Special. Expect satisfying over fancy: big flavors, shareable pies, and sauces that win fans, though there are occasional off nights where crust runs dry or a takeout item goes missing. Ideal if you crave comfort over ceremony. Families are well served here. Kids gravitate to chicken tenders and spaghetti, while shareable pizzas, calzones, and mozzarella sticks keep everyone happy. The menu is accessible for picky eaters, with vegetarian pizzas and toppings; gluten-free crust has been reported by diners, but confirm availability and limitations (wings are pre-breaded).
At a Glance
- Crisp, thin-crust NY-style pizza with big, shareable portions
- Friendly, accommodating staff and convenient location for Haleakala trips
- Occasional inconsistency (dry crust, cold takeout, missing ingredients)
- Small, simple space; phone ordering responsiveness can lag
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- Large, shareable portions
- Local twist pizza (Kalua pork)
- Convenient Haleakala stop
What People Love
- Hearty portions that feed two with leftovers
- Crispy hand-tossed crust and flavorful sauce
- Genuinely kind, laid-back service
- Locally-influenced Kalua Pork pizza
Points of Concern
- Sporadic execution misses: a few reports of very hard crust or cold, soggy takeout
- Order accuracy hiccups: one takeout Alfredo missing chicken; advise checking bags
- Phone responsiveness complaints; expect delays at peak times
- Review patterns show occasional polarization but no manipulation signals; experiences can vary by night
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$28-42 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Share a large specialty pizza ($31-35) for value
- Add a veggie-forward pie (Primavera/Old World) to balance richer choices
- Gluten-avoiders: confirm GF crust and topping policies before ordering
Perfect For
- Pre/post-Haleakala fueling stop
- Casual family dinner with shareable plates
- Group takeout back at the rental
- Low-key date night with pizza and appetizers
Location Insights
Area: Upcountry Maui small-town vibe with locals and Haleakala-bound visitors; casual and unfussy.
Safety: Generally safe, small-town environment with steady foot traffic in evenings.
Nearby: Convenient stop en route to/from Haleakala; mixed shops and services nearby in Makawao.
MakawaoMakawao is a historic paniolo (Hawaiian cowboy) town with a strong arts community and a relaxed, small-town vibe. The dining scene here features farm-to-table restaurants, casual eateries, and spots emphasizing local ingredients and Hawaiian flavors, attracting both locals and tourists looking for a unique, less commercialized experience.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–22:00
Tuesday11:00–22:00
Wednesday11:00–22:00
Thursday11:00–22:00
Friday11:00–22:00
Saturday11:00–22:00
Sunday11:00–22:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →