Reliable NY-style slices with a big menu and late-night convenience on 16th Street Mall, though service speed and slice freshness vary at busy times.
Brooklyn's Finest Pizza delivers solid neighborhood pizza shop quality with strong food quality anchored by crisp, foldable NY-style slices and friendly service. However, inconsistent slice freshness during peak times and variable service speed prevent a higher grade—ordering whole pies mitigates freshness concerns. The convenient downtown mall location with outdoor seating makes it a reliable casual stop rather than a destination.
On the 16th Street Mall, this spot feels warm and bustling, the kind of counter-service pizzeria where slices fly and sports hum on TV. Reviewers praise the crisp foldable crust and say staff are often friendly and accommodating. One diner summed it up: "Large, crispy slices that hit the spot after a long day." The cooking leans classic NY slice shop with a broad menu: by-the-slice cheese and pepperoni, hefty specialties like New York, New York and The Godfather, plus Detroit and Sicilian options. Think comfort-first pies with Americanized riffs like Buffalo or BBQ chicken. Quality is generally solid, though a few report dried or older slices during peak swings—ordering fresh pies avoids that risk. Families will find it easy: pizza, mozzarella sticks, fries, and even gluten-free and vegan crust options for dietary needs. Portions are generous and the vibe is casual and kid-friendly. No kids menu needed when cheese slices and garlic knots do the trick; outdoor seating helps with strollers and quick meals.
Area vibe: Pedestrian mall with tourists, office workers, and event traffic; lively and casual with fluctuating crowds.
Safety: Generally busy and well-trafficked; occasional complaints about upkeep and facilities typical of downtown corridors.
What's nearby: Near hotels, shops, bars, and transit shuttles; convenient for quick meals before events and after nightlife.