Lively neighborhood seafood spot with strong happy hour and crowd-pleasing staples; great for oysters, lobster rolls, and cocktails, but entrees and service can be inconsistent during rushes.
Max Gill & Grill delivers reliable neighborhood seafood dining with strong food quality anchored by excellent oysters, chowder, and lobster rolls. However, inconsistent execution on certain entrees and service slowdowns during peak periods prevent a higher grade. The appealing South Gaylord location with popular patio and loyal repeat customer base make it a solid choice for happy hour and seafood appetizers, though full entree reliability falls short of grade A standards.
One caveat: Kitchen gets backed up at busy times leading to slow tickets