Seemor
Nantucket › Nantucket › Cisco Brewers
Cisco BrewersB-Worth Trying
5 Bartlett Farm Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554
· Brewery, Beer garden, Distillery
· 4.4/5 Google (496 reviews)
Delivery
Destination brewery campus with live music, multiple bars, and food trucks; fantastic vibe but can be crowded with lines, covers, and inconsistent service at peak times.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Cisco Brewers delivers a lively island experience anchored by exceptional outdoor setting appeal and strong destination appeal, but inconsistent food and service execution and crowding during peak season prevent a higher grade. The venue excels as a social gathering spot with rotating food trucks and live music, though peak-time waits, cover charges, and occasional door-staff friction temper the experience for some visitors. Best enjoyed during off-peak hours or with realistic expectations about summer crowds.
Restaurant Summary
Set on a breezy campus west of town, Cisco Brewers feels like an island block party with live bands and picnic tables. Reviewers rave about the sunny courtyard energy and say things like, "It turned into an afternoon hangout before we knew it." Lines and cover charges appear on peak weekends, but off-peak it flows like a relaxed seaside fair. Food comes from rotating trucks and a raw bar, so the cooking leans classic, crowd-pleasing rather than chefly fireworks. Think lobster rolls, oysters, wood-fired pizza, tacos, and BBQ to pair with beers, seltzers, cocktails, and wine. Beer quality gets plenty of love, though a few enthusiasts find it uneven; most people come for the scene plus a cold pint. Families show up in force, especially daytime, with pizza and fries standing in for a kids menu. That said, space can be tight and music loud during peak hours. If you need a stroller-friendly corner, arrive early or target off-peak times when the crowds thin.
At a Glance
- Lively outdoor campus with daily-in-season live music and multiple bars
- Wide variety of food trucks and a raw bar for diverse tastes
- Peak-season lines, cover charges ($10-20), and limited seating
- Mixed reports on door/security attitude and tour reliability
- Shuttle from town, bike-friendly access
What Sets It Apart
- brewery_distillery_winery_on_one_campus
- live_music_daily_in_season
- free_town_shuttle
What People Love
- Feel-good band energy that turns into a mini festival
- Beer flights and cocktails for every palate
- Fresh oysters and lobster rolls
- Dog-friendly, open-air vibe
- Easy shuttle from town
Points of Concern
- Cover charges and event pricing can surprise first-timers
- Crowding leads to long lines and standing-room only during summer weekends
- Door and security staff described as rude by several reviewers
- Tour availability inconsistently honored; call ahead to confirm
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$32-48 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Based on review mentions, pair oysters or a lobster roll with a hazy IPA; pizza is a safe, shareable choice.
Perfect For
- Sunny afternoon with friends and live music
- Casual group meetups before or after the beach
- Visitors seeking a signature Nantucket hangout
- Mixed groups with varied drink preferences
Location Insights
Area: Relaxed coastal light-industrial edge near Bartlett’s Farm; draws island visitors and groups for afternoons.
Safety: Generally safe, busy during season; crowding and parking frustrations reported at peak.
Nearby: Near beaches, bike routes, Bartlett’s Farm; shuttle from town and on-site parking noted.
SiasconsetSiasconset, often called 'Sconset, is a picturesque village on the eastern end of Nantucket Island known for its historic cottages, scenic ocean views, and a laid-back atmosphere. The dining scene here is casual and often centered around fresh seafood and local craft beverages, appealing to visitors seeking a quintessential island experience.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday14:00–19:00
Tuesday14:00–19:00
Wednesday14:00–19:00
Thursday14:00–19:00
Friday12:00–19:00
Saturday12:00–19:00
Sunday12:00–18:00
Available: Delivery
View full analysis on Seemor →