Seemor
Molly's Shebeen Bar + RestaurantA-Worth Trying
287 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10010
· Irish pub, Bar, Hamburger restaurant
· 4.5/5 Google (1156 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Cozy old-school Irish pub with standout comfort dishes and a great Guinness pour; lively, friendly vibe with occasional service slowdowns and rare but sharp service complaints.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
Molly's Shebeen delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality in classic pub fare and reliable service, though occasional peak-time slowdowns and tight seating constraints prevent higher distinction. The authentic pub charm and loyal multi-decade following reflect genuine neighborhood appeal, positioning it competitively among respected local favorites rather than as a destination standout.
Restaurant Summary
Step inside for the warm glow, low ceilings, and cozy pub charm that regulars rave about. Bartenders pour a textbook Guinness and servers juggle crowds with smiles; one guest shared, "the pie arrived steaming and perfect." At peak hours it can feel lively and bustling, especially around holidays and big games, yet the room keeps its authentic character. The cooking leans classic and hearty rather than flashy—think shepherd’s pie, fish and chips, curry fries, and a proper Reuben. It is comfort-forward, consistent when not slammed, and most dishes arrive hot and generous. If you want refined plating, look elsewhere; if you want warm, satisfying plates with a well-poured pint, you are in the right place. For families, the menu is naturally kid-friendly with burgers and fries, hot dogs, and mild fish and chips. There is no explicit kids menu, but portions are shareable and sides like plain fries or mozzarella sticks help. Adventurous items exist, yet plenty of familiar choices make it easy for younger eaters.
At a Glance
- Excellent shepherd’s pie and fish and chips with generous portions
- Perfectly poured Guinness and welcoming staff
- Service can slow when understaffed during peak times
- A few sharp service complaints amid many positives
- Busy on holidays and game days; expect waits
What Sets It Apart
- classic_wood_clad_interior
- notable_guinness_pour
- beloved_holiday_decor
- irish_comfort_food_focus
What People Love
- The cozy, wood-lined interior with real pub character
- Shepherd’s pie that arrives piping hot
- Crispy fish and chips with tasty tartar
- A perfect Guinness pour that feels special
- Friendly staff who remember regulars
Points of Concern
- Service pace can lag when only one server covers the floor during rushes (occasional reports)
- Isolated incidents of rude interactions at the bar contrast with the general friendliness
- Kitchen hours may end earlier than expected late-night; confirm before arriving
- Pricing is Midtown-Manhattan pub level; some find it high despite large portions
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$42-$58 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Pair shepherd’s pie with a Guinness for the classic combo
- Add curry sauce to fries or wings for extra kick
- For lighter fare, choose House Salad and add grilled salmon ($12)
Perfect For
- Casual pints and hearty comfort food
- Watching a game with friends
- Holiday-season pub vibes and decorations
- A relaxed neighborhood dinner after Madison Square Park
Location Insights
Area: Lively Manhattan corridor near Gramercy/NoMad; after-work and weekend crowd with sports watchers.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked avenues with good lighting and steady foot traffic.
Nearby: Near Madison Square Park, offices, apartments, and popular holiday spots like Rolf's.
GramercyGramercy offers a mix of historic charm and modern sophistication, with a calm, residential feel complemented by trendy restaurants, boutique bars, and upscale dining venues. The area attracts diners looking for quality food in a relaxed yet stylish atmosphere.
NoMadNoMad (North of Madison Square Park) is known for its lively dining scene featuring innovative restaurants, gastropubs, and boutique hotels. It draws a crowd interested in contemporary cuisine and a vibrant nightlife, blending business and leisure.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–04:00
Tuesday11:00–04:00
Wednesday11:00–04:00
Thursday11:00–04:00
Friday11:00–04:00
Saturday11:00–04:00
Sunday11:00–04:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →