A busy, central Italian spot that wins on atmosphere, pizzas, pasta, and broad crowd-pleasing appeal, but it can feel rushed, cramped, and inconsistent enough to annoy diners who expect polished service.
Amarone delivers solid neighborhood Italian dining anchored by exceptional setting appeal in a historic central Edinburgh location and strong design quality that create genuine atmosphere. Reliable food quality and generally warm service make it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants, though inconsistent preparation and service variability under peak pressure prevent a higher grade. Best suited for groups and families seeking familiar Italian comfort rather than culinary adventure.
One caveat: Some diners found the room overly crowded, noisy, or packed too tightly for a relaxed chat.