Cozy modern-Scottish bistro with standout seafood and warm service; a few service-policy hiccups and occasional inconsistency, but strong overall value for the area.
First Coast delivers solid neighborhood bistro dining with excellent seafood execution and warm, attentive service, but inconsistent execution on risotto and sides prevents a higher grade. The modern Scottish approach and central Haymarket location appeal to seafood lovers seeking reliable quality without pretension, though occasional policy friction and modest space comfort keep it competitive rather than exceptional within the area's dining landscape.
One caveat: A minority of visits cite undercooked risotto or pasta; appears to be occasional rather than systemic