A stylish central Edinburgh hotel restaurant and bar that shines for afternoon tea, steaks, and warm service, but the restaurant experience can be uneven and occasionally overpriced for the level of execution.
Malmaison Edinburgh City delivers strong food quality anchored by praised steaks and afternoon tea, paired with attentive service that earns consistent recognition. However, inconsistency across meal periods, particularly breakfast and Sunday lunch, prevents a higher grade. The stylish St Andrew Square setting and reliable hospitality keep it a solid choice for hotel dining, though execution remains uneven enough to hold it back from excellence.
One caveat: Breakfast gets the most criticism, especially when plates are slow, eggs are overcooked, or the buffet feels sparse.