Seemor
MathersC+Worth Trying
25 Broughton St, Edinburgh EH1 3JU
· Pub, Restaurant, Sports bar
· 4.5/5 Google (269 reviews)
Reservations
Classic Edinburgh pub for well kept cask ales, sports, and occasional live jazz; friendly most days, but service mood can swing.
Why it gets a C+ for overall quality
Mathers delivers dependable pub experience through well-maintained cask ales and clean operations and generally friendly, fast service, earning its grade C+ standing. However, limited food offerings (snacks only) and occasional service tone inconsistencies prevent a higher grade. For beer enthusiasts and locals seeking conversation-friendly atmosphere with reliable pints, it's a worthwhile neighborhood destination—just not a culinary one.
Restaurant Summary
A locals-forward spot just off the bustle, Mathers feels like a classic Edinburgh pub: polished wood, conversation-friendly volume, and beer lines that fans rave about. One regular summed it up: "A proper pint and space to chat." Expect sports on big screens and the occasional live jazz set. The culinary approach leans traditional pub-drinks first with well kept cask ales and a straightforward spirits list. There is no kitchen service now, only hot cabinet snacks, so come for pints, not plates. That aligns with a classic, comfort-first model rather than innovation, ideal for beer lovers and casual meetups. Families can be comfortable earlier in the day thanks to moderate noise and seating, but note the lack of a food menu and kid-specific options. If young ones need a meal, plan nearby dining first, then pop in for a quick drink.
At a Glance
- Well kept cask ales and clean lines praised repeatedly
- Cozy, conversation-friendly pub off the main tourist drag
- Live jazz/blues some Sundays and reliable sports viewing
- Service tone can swing; a few reports of rude interactions
- Limited food (snacks only), cocktails not guaranteed
What Sets It Apart
- well_kept_cask_ales
- live_jazz_sundays
- locals_favorite_off_main_drag
What People Love
- Warm, classic pub feel
- Knowledgeable bar team on beers
- Reasonable central pricing
- Sunday jazz sessions
Points of Concern
- Intermittent service rudeness called out in a handful of reviews; varies by staff and time
- No kitchen; only hot cabinet snacks, so not suitable for a meal
- Occasional stock outages (e.g., Guinness) at opening or busy periods
- Pricing perceptions vary; a few feel pints are pricey for the setting
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£12-22 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Based on reviews only: prioritize cask ales and local lagers; do not plan a meal here.
Perfect For
- A proper pint before or after sightseeing
- Watching Premier League with locals
- Low-key date over ales
- Solo wind-down at a window seat
Location Insights
Area: Edge of New Town near Broughton Street; local-heavy, relaxed, close to city centre but off main tourist drags.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked central streets; typical city vigilance at night.
Nearby: Near restaurants, bars, and shops; convenient for pre-theatre or post-sightseeing drinks; Fringe venues reachable.
Old TownThe dining scene in Old Town is diverse, ranging from traditional Scottish pubs and casual eateries to upscale restaurants and trendy cafes. The atmosphere is lively and often busy, especially during tourist seasons and festivals, with a mix of historic charm and contemporary urban energy.
SouthsideSouthside is a vibrant sub-area within Old Town, known for its eclectic mix of independent shops, affordable dining options, and a youthful, creative vibe influenced by nearby university campuses.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–23:00
Tuesday12:00–23:00
Wednesday12:00–23:00
Thursday12:00–23:00
Friday12:00–00:00
Saturday12:00–00:00
Sunday12:00–23:00
Available: Reservations
View full analysis on Seemor →