Creative six-course tasting menus that rotate by theme deliver strong value and lively service, but the experience can be polarizing for conservative palates and during peak times.
Six by Nico Edinburgh delivers vibrant, polished food quality and strong staff knowledge that exceed typical neighborhood standards, supported by creative themed menus at competitive pricing. However, noticeable consistency variance—including oversalting, pacing gaps, and occasional execution slips—prevents grade A territory, while tight seating and uneven comfort limit the overall experience. Best suited for diners who embrace culinary surprise and can navigate variable peak-time service.
The room feels lively and buzzing in New Town, with servers presenting each course like a mini show-and-tell. Guests describe playful plates and a sense of occasion, noting that team members like Alfie and Faith keep service warm and attentive. Some nights hum harder than others, and a few diners found the pace uneven at peak times. The culinary approach leans contemporary and theme-driven: creative tasting menus that rotate across ideas like San Sebastian, Space, and Mad Hatter, backed by confident wine or cocktail pairings. When it clicks, dishes feel polished and smart for the price; when it misses, you may get oversalting or a course that reads more concept than comfort. It suits diners who like surprise and storytelling with their meal. Families can make it work for celebrations, especially with older kids who enjoy a showpiece meal, but there is no classic kids menu. Expect adventurous flavors, smaller courses, and occasional strong seasonings. Items like warm sourdough and croquetas are more approachable, while themed seafood or boldly seasoned plates may challenge picky eaters. For a smoother experience, consider earlier seatings and discuss dietary adjustments in advance.
Area vibe: Elegant Georgian streets in New Town with boutiques, offices, and upscale bars drawing a mix of professionals and visitors.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and busy in evenings due to nearby dining and retail corridors.
What's nearby: Steps from George Street retail and bars, close to Princes Street and attractions; strong foot traffic and after-work crowd.