A warm, family-friendly Italian spot with standout pizza, solid pasta and desserts, and generally strong value, though seating is compact and a few service/value complaints should be noted.
That Amore delivers exceptional food quality anchored by consistently praised pizza, pasta, and tiramisu, paired with genuinely warm and attentive service that keeps guests returning. The modest neighborhood setting and solid execution across all dimensions create a reliable, unpretentious dining experience, though it remains a local favorite rather than a destination draw.
That’s Amore comes across like a compact neighborhood trattoria that punches above its weight. Reviewers keep circling back to the same mood: warm, friendly, cozy, and very pizza-forward, with one guest saying the staff made them feel “right at home” and another calling the room “immaculately finished.” It is the kind of place people seem to discover once, then mentally file under “return here soon.” The cooking leans classic Italian rather than experimental, but the execution feels confident: crisp-chewy dough, fresh toppings, solid pasta, and a dessert list that gets real praise, especially the tiramisu. The menu is broad enough for a casual mixed group, but pizza is clearly the headline act, with a few more inventive white-base options if you want to wander slightly off the standard path. It suits diners who want comfort, flavor, and a family-friendly room more than theatrics. For kids, this is an easy win. The menu has obvious crowd-pleasers like pizza, fries, ice cream, focaccia, and even flexible requests such as butter spaghetti were reportedly handled without fuss. Families repeatedly describe it as a good meal-out spot, so unless your child only eats extremely plain food, this should work well.
Area vibe: Residential and student-oriented area with casual dining and local services.
Safety: Generally safe with active foot traffic and decent evening lighting near main streets.
What's nearby: Near Edinburgh University campuses, local shops, Blackford Hill and bus routes into city centre.