Seemor
The Bailie BarA-Worth Trying
2-4 St Stephen St, Edinburgh EH3 5AL
· Pub, Bar, Restaurant
· 4.6/5 Google (1172 reviews)
Outdoor seating
A characterful Stockbridge pub with warmly attentive service, reliably good pub classics, and fair prices, best for cozy meals and a pint rather than cutting-edge cuisine.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
The Bailie Bar delivers warm, attentive service and solid food quality anchored by reliable pub classics—fish and chips, soups, and hearty Scottish staples executed with care. The cozy Stockbridge basement setting with fireplace character creates genuine neighborhood appeal, though tight quarters when crowded and occasional cooking inconsistencies prevent grade A territory. A competitive neighborhood favorite with loyal following and fair value.
Restaurant Summary
Down a few steps in Stockbridge, The Bailie Bar hums with a cozy locals-first vibe—worn wood, a fireplace glow, and staff who seem to remember you even if it is your first time. Diners talk about "proper pub comfort" and a pint poured with care, while one guest said the team made them feel like a regular on day one. Service reads as warm and attentive, and the room can turn lively when a match is on, but it rarely feels chaotic thanks to thoughtful table spacing and a welcome-you-in energy. The cooking leans traditional and satisfying rather than flashy, a comfort-forward kitchen where soups, fish and chips, haggis, and burgers lead the way. Specials like mixed grill or smoked haddock risotto add a little ambition, but the heart of the place is pub classics done right. The culinary approach is familiar and ingredient-led: hearty Scottish staples with consistent seasoning and sensible portions, best for those who want flavor and warmth over experimentation. Families will find this kid-friendly in practice thanks to burgers, ham-egg-chips, a small fish portion, and ice cream. There is no explicit kids menu listed, but options are straightforward and recognizable. One reviewer flagged a baby policy concern, so families with infants may want to call ahead. Otherwise, the mix of simple mains and desserts should suit most children, and staff are happy to tweak an order when asked.
At a Glance
- Welcoming, attentive staff with genuine neighborhood charm
- Reliable pub classics—soups, fish and chips, haggis—praised across many reviews
- Fair prices for the area; hearty portions on staples
- Can be busy and reserved at peak; space feels tight when packed
- Occasional inconsistencies (overcooked fish or dry sandwich reported in older reviews)
What Sets It Apart
- classic_stockbridge_basement_pub
- strong_local_regulars_scene
- cozy_fireplace_ambience
What People Love
- That locals actually drink and dine here
- Soup of the day that tastes slow-cooked
- Crisp, satisfying fish and chips
- Staff who make newcomers feel like regulars
Points of Concern
- Peak times often see many tables reserved; consider booking or arriving early
- A few reports of uneven cooking (overcooked fish, dry steak ciabatta) though recent trend is positive
- Space can feel dark or tight when crowded
- One complaint noted a baby policy; check ahead if visiting with infants
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£29-39 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Choose mid-priced mains (£10-£12) for best value; add a £9.50-£12 starter to share
- If you want seafood, opt for Fish of the Day size that matches your appetite to control spend
- Vegetarians can pair bruschetta or soup with the veggie curry or falafel burger
Perfect For
- A cozy pub dinner after exploring Stockbridge
- Cask ale and whisky with comfort food
- Casual group catch-ups during a match
- Solo bar meal with friendly chat
Location Insights
Area: Leafy, village-like enclave just northwest of the city centre, popular with professionals, students, and long-time locals.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and busy in evenings due to bar and dining scene.
Nearby: Near independent shops on St Stephen Street, Water of Leith walks, and Stockbridge Market on weekends.
New TownThe dining scene in New Town is diverse, featuring a mix of high-end restaurants, trendy cafes, and traditional pubs. The area attracts a cosmopolitan crowd seeking quality dining experiences in a stylish and historic setting, with a lively yet refined social atmosphere.
St Stephen Street areaThis micro-neighborhood around St Stephen Street is characterized by a quieter, more intimate dining environment compared to the busier Princes Street nearby. It offers a selection of boutique eateries and bars popular with locals and professionals looking for relaxed yet sophisticated options.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–00:00
Tuesday11:00–00:00
Wednesday11:00–00:00
Thursday11:00–00:00
Friday11:00–01:00
Saturday11:00–01:00
Sunday11:00–00:00
Available: Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →