Seemor
The Colony GourmetB+Worth Trying
58 Home St, Edinburgh EH3 9NA
· Restaurant, Cafe, Takeaway
· 4.7/5 Google (323 reviews)
Takeout
Charming Brazilian/Portuguese-leaning cafe with excellent coffee, comfy lounge seating, and strong value; occasional complaints about savory items and noise keep it from being flawless.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
The Colony Gourmet delivers solid neighborhood cafe quality through excellent specialty coffee and pastries paired with genuinely warm, attentive service and thoughtful design with a welcoming back lounge. Occasional variability in savory items and basic menu guidance prevent a higher grade, though strong value and loyal following position it as a reliable local favorite worth visiting for coffee and baked goods.
Restaurant Summary
Just off Home Street, this spot feels like a small front counter that opens into a surprisingly generous lounge where people settle into sofas under a bright mural. The vibe is warm and unhurried, with many calling out friendly baristas and that tucked-away back room. One diner summed it up: "We came for a cappuccino and pastry, then ended up lingering." Value is a clear draw and the overall tone is neighborhood gem rather than scene-chasing cafe. The cooking leans classic cafe with Brazilian and Portuguese touches: pastel de nata, pao de queijo, coxinha, and well-pulled flat whites. The culinary approach is elevated comfort (innovation level 4.0): familiar snacks done neatly, plus a few regional specialties that broaden the spectrum without getting fancy. Coffee quality is the headline; savory bakes and brioche can delight, though a few guests found some items basic or lukewarm, so stick to the strengths if you are picky. For families, it is easygoing and informal with kid-friendly options like croissants, muffins, soup, and simple sandwiches. There is no kids menu, but prices are gentle and portions are appropriate. Seating is relaxed and staff have been kind to four-legged friends, which tends to make the space feel welcome for all.
At a Glance
- Excellent specialty coffee and standout pastries at budget-friendly prices
- Comfy back lounge with sofas, mural, and relaxed study vibe
- Occasional complaints about savory items being basic or not hot enough
- Noise can spike if staff conversations carry in the front area
- Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food
What Sets It Apart
- lounge_style_back_room_with_mural
- brazilian_portuguese_bakery_items
- dog_friendly_with_beds_and_bowls
What People Love
- Smooth, well-balanced coffee drinks
- Portuguese sweets like pastel de nata
- The cozy back room with plants and a mural
- Genuinely friendly, welcoming service
- Good value for central Edinburgh
Points of Concern
- Some savory items described as basic or served lukewarm; consider sticking to coffee and pastries if sensitive to this
- One-off cleanliness and underbaked pastry complaints from 2023; not a recurring theme recently
- Noise flare-ups reported when staff chat near the counter
- Limited options for conservative palates or picky eaters if expecting a full hot kitchen menu
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost£9-13 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Start with a flat white (£2.20) and pastel de nata (~£2); add pao de queijo for a savory contrast; if you want something heartier, a quiche (~€4.50) is the fuller option.
Perfect For
- A relaxed coffee and pastry before or after the Cameo Cinema
- Long catch-up chats on comfy sofas
- Solo laptop sessions with a flat white
- Quick budget-friendly breakfast on the go
Location Insights
Area: Lively city-center fringe near Tollcross with students, locals, and theater-goers; casual day-time energy.
Safety: Generally safe with steady foot traffic; standard city awareness applies.
Nearby: Near Cameo Cinema and Bruntsfield/Lothian Road corridors; mix of cafes, bars, and small shops.
West EndThe West End of New Town is characterized by elegant townhouses, boutique hotels, and a variety of dining options ranging from casual cafes to fine dining. It attracts a mix of locals and visitors seeking a refined yet lively atmosphere with easy access to the city center.
Home Street AreaHome Street is a quieter, more residential micro-neighborhood within the West End, known for its charming streets and proximity to cultural institutions like the Edinburgh International Conference Centre. Dining here tends to be intimate and sophisticated, catering to both locals and business visitors.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday08:00–17:00
Tuesday08:00–17:00
Wednesday08:00–17:00
Thursday08:00–17:00
Friday08:00–17:00
Saturday09:00–17:00
Sunday09:00–17:00
Available: Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →