Seemor
The Scran and ScallieA-Worth Trying
1 Comely Bank Rd, Edinburgh EH4 1DR
· Gastropub
· 4.5/5 Google (2531 reviews)
Reservations
A polished Scottish gastropub delivering standout pies, fish and chips, oysters and sticky toffee pudding with warm ambiance and generally attentive service—tasty but priced on the higher side.
Why it gets an A- for overall quality
The Scran and Scallie delivers exceptional food quality anchored by standout dishes like steak pie and sticky toffee pudding, supported by strong service attentiveness and a charming Stockbridge setting. Consistency shows occasional variation in execution, and service reliability varies by server, preventing grade A territory. A competitive gastropub that delivers refined Scottish comfort dining with reliable quality.
Restaurant Summary
Set in Stockbridge, the room feels warm and bustling without tipping into chaos, with locals and visitors sharing booths and window seats. Service is often friendly and on point, and dishes like oysters and pies carry that polished pub comfort. One diner put it best: "the pie was outstanding and the pudding sealed the night." The cooking leans elevated and ingredient-led rather than flashy—classic Scottish comfort done right with careful sourcing and technique. The culinary approach leans elevated traditional: modern polish on crowd-pleasers like steak pie, fish and chips, and haggis. If you like refined pub fare at a chef-driven level, this hits the mark. Families fit in here. There are plenty of familiar options for kids—fish and chips, burgers, and sides like chips or mash—and desserts that win smiles. It can be lively with children at peak times, and a small kids area exists though smaller than some expect.
At a Glance
- Elevated Scottish classics with consistently praised steak pie and sticky toffee pudding
- Cozy Stockbridge setting with welcoming vibe
- Pricing runs high for a gastropub; some mains require added sides
- Service can vary by server, from stellar to curt on occasion
What Sets It Apart
- elevated_scottish_classics
- stockbridge_neighborhood_charm
- marrow_bone_pie_presentation
What People Love
- Rich, comforting steak and marrow pie
- Crisp, well-seasoned fish and chips
- Memorable sticky toffee pudding finish
- Attentive staff who explain specials and pair drinks
Points of Concern
- Pricing feels premium for portions according to several diners
- Occasional execution slips (thick or undercooked batter, lukewarm pie)
- Service inconsistency reported across a few tables
- Some substitutions or policy changes not communicated clearly
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost£48-62 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians: spelt & lentil burger or beetroot salad
- Seafood fans: fish pie or pan-roasted cod
- Sweet tooth: sticky toffee pudding or rice pudding with rum raisins
Perfect For
- A cozy date night with Scottish comfort food
- Treating visiting friends to elevated pub classics
- A relaxed family meal with familiar dishes
- Pre- or post-walk lunch around Stockbridge
Location Insights
Area: Leafy Stockbridge setting with village feel; mix of locals, professionals, and visitors exploring boutiques and galleries.
Safety: Well-kept and busy by day and evening; generally safe with good lighting and foot traffic.
Nearby: Near Water of Leith, independent shops, bars, and IJ Mellis cheesemonger; residential streets around.
Comely BankComely Bank is a quiet, residential neighborhood with a mix of Victorian and Edwardian homes. The dining scene is modest but includes a selection of local cafes, pubs, and casual eateries catering mostly to residents and visitors seeking a relaxed atmosphere away from the busier city center.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:00–21:00
Tuesday12:00–21:00
Wednesday12:00–21:00
Thursday12:00–21:00
Friday12:00–21:00
Saturday12:00–21:00
Sunday12:00–21:00
Available: Reservations
View full analysis on Seemor →