Handmade-pasta spot across from Second City with beloved free garlic-mascarpone bread, strong service, and a few standout pastas, but consistency varies and pricing is on the higher side.
Gussie's Handmade Italian delivers solid neighborhood dining with attentive, knowledgeable service and strong food quality when execution peaks—the signature garlic-mascarpone bread and handmade pastas earn genuine loyalty. However, inconsistent pasta texture and seasoning across dishes and nights prevents grade A territory, and tight seating limits the dining experience. The convenient Second City location and generous portions offer solid value for an upscale neighborhood spot.
One caveat: Occasional bland or overcooked pastas, especially carbonara, noted by multiple diners