Seemor

Gussie's Handmade ItalianBWorth Trying

Name: Gussie's Handmade Italian
Address: 227 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60610, Chicago, United States
Rating: 4.5

227 W North Ave, Chicago, IL 60610 · Italian restaurant, Northern Italian restaurant · 4.5/5 Google (509 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout

Handmade-pasta spot across from Second City with beloved free garlic-mascarpone bread, strong service, and a few standout pastas, but consistency varies and pricing is on the higher side.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Gussie's Handmade Italian delivers solid neighborhood dining with attentive, knowledgeable service and strong food quality when execution peaks—the signature garlic-mascarpone bread and handmade pastas earn genuine loyalty. However, inconsistent pasta texture and seasoning across dishes and nights prevents grade A territory, and tight seating limits the dining experience. The convenient Second City location and generous portions offer solid value for an upscale neighborhood spot.

Restaurant Summary

Steps from The Second City, the room feels warm and bustling with servers who know the menu and a signature free round of garlic-mascarpone bread that many call irresistible. One diner noted it was “the perfect pre-show stop,” though a few mentioned tight seating or a manager presence that felt a bit stiff. Overall, energy leans convivial without becoming chaotic. The cooking leans classic Northern Italian with a comfort-forward mindset: handmade pastas, slow-braised ragus, bright lemon-caper chicken, and seafood linguine. When the kitchen hits, plates like wild boar pappardelle and chicken piccata sing; on off nights, a few found carbonara bland or overcooked. Prices track the neighborhood and quality, and the complimentary bread bolsters value. Families fit right in. There is a dedicated kids menu (spaghetti and ravioli), and plenty of approachable pastas for selective eaters. If your crew skews seafood-averse or sensitive to garlic, choose simpler shapes or tomato-based dishes and skip heavier specials.

At a Glance

Complimentary garlic-mascarpone bread is a crowd favorite
Knowledgeable, friendly servers with thoughtful recommendations
Convenient pre- and post-show location by Second City with garage parking
Pasta texture and seasoning consistency vary by dish and night
Seating can feel tight; occasional management aloofness

What Sets It Apart

complimentary_garlic_mascarpone_bread
across_from_second_city
handmade_pasta_focus

What People Love

That warm, garlicky bread ritual that starts the meal
Handmade pastas with rich, comforting sauces
Servers who guide choices confidently
A lively, convenient setting near theaters

Points of Concern

Occasional bland or overcooked pastas, especially carbonara, noted by multiple diners
Some seafood quality slips (sandy mussels once; one illness claim) suggest vigilance on QC
Tight seating and odd table assignments reported at peak times
3% card surcharge mentioned by a diner may surprise guests

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost$48-$66 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

For milder palates, choose spaghetti with blistered tomatoes ($19.95) or ravioli ($21.95)
Seafood fans: try Linguine all’ Vongole ($29.95) or Bronzino all’ Puttanesca ($32.95)

Perfect For

Pre-show dinner before The Second City
Casual date night with wine and pasta
Family outing with kids who like simple pastas
Out-of-town visitors seeking handmade pasta

Location Insights

Area: Old Town near Second City; lively pre- and post-show crowd with date nights and small groups.

Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked nightlife corridor; occasional street noise near entrance.

Nearby: Directly across from The Second City; bars, cafes, and mixed residential nearby; garage parking across the street.

Old TownOld Town is characterized by its charming historic architecture, boutique shops, and a strong dining scene featuring a mix of casual and upscale restaurants. The area attracts diners looking for authentic and artisanal food experiences in a walkable, neighborhood-centric atmosphere.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday Tuesday17:00–21:00 Wednesday17:00–21:00 Thursday17:00–21:00 Friday16:30–22:00 Saturday16:30–22:00 Sunday17:00–21:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →