Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Creative Detroit-style pies and a cult-favorite burger near Broadway; tasty and fun, but service inconsistency, noise, and pricing transparency (vegan/gluten-free) can frustrate.
Emmy Squared Pizza delivers solid neighborhood dining with strong food quality anchored by distinctive Detroit-style crust and a beloved burger, but inconsistent execution—ranging from perfectly caramelized pies to undercooked centers—prevents a higher grade. Service varies noticeably between attentive and slow, and the compact space can feel cramped during peak hours, though the Hell's Kitchen location makes it convenient for theater-goers and families seeking creative comfort food.
Steps from the theaters, the room feels warm and bustling, with bar seats, cozy tables, and pies parading by. One diner summed it up: "crunchy crust, tangy sauce, and friendly servers." At peak, it can tip into pretty loud, and service pace varies, but on good nights staff keep waters topped and leftovers boxed with care. The cooking leans creative comfort food more than purist Italian: Detroit-style squares with caramelized cheese rims, hot-honey heat, and a beloved pretzel-bun burger with waffle fries. The culinary approach feels contemporary and ingredient-focused: clever combos and solid technique without fine-dining theatrics. When the oven is dialed, pizzas sing; off days bring underbaked middles or salty edges. Families do well here thanks to a real kids menu (pizza sticks, bites, burger) and shareable mozz sticks and fries. Picky eaters can stick to simple cheese or a kids burger, while adventurous teens may love spicy-sweet pies. Note: standard crust contains butter; vegan cheese is available with extra charges, and gluten-free availability varies—confirm before you promise a kid their favorite.
Area: Busy Theater District fringe spot drawing pre/post-show crowds, tourists, and locals seeking casual bites.
Safety: High foot traffic and lighting typical for Broadway zone; generally safe with occasional late-night bustle.
Nearby: Near Times Square, Broadway theaters, hotels, and bars; strong pre-theater demand and takeout activity.
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →