Neighborhood slice shop with standout grandma and Sicilian pizza, fair prices, and strong owner engagement, but mixed reports on counter service and delivery consistency.
Fazio's earns its grade through excellent pizza quality—particularly grandma and Sicilian slices with crisp crust and bright sauce—and genuine neighborhood appeal with loyal regulars and fair pricing. However, inconsistent execution and variable service politeness prevent higher standing, while the modest counter-and-stools setting lacks destination appeal. Best experienced fresh at the counter rather than via delivery.
One caveat: Delivery can arrive soggy or with topping slide, especially via third-party apps