Seemor
Marty's Martini BarB-Worth Trying
1477 W Winnemac Ave, Chicago, IL 60640
· Cocktail bar
· 4.7/5 Google (495 reviews)
Outdoor seating
Beloved neighborhood martini bar with creative drinks and cozy, lively vibes; expect crowds, standing room, and counter ordering on busy nights.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
Marty's Martini Bar delivers solid neighborhood bar quality anchored by strong, well-executed cocktails and distinctive Paris-inspired decor with seasonal appeal. However, drink consistency slips during peak service and tight quarters with frequent standing limit the experience. The bar excels at what it is—a lively, festive cocktail destination—but operational constraints prevent a higher grade.
Restaurant Summary
The scene is warm and bustling, with Parisian-leaning decor, holiday flare, and a crowd that turns the room lively fast. One guest summed it up: "It is loud and busy, but that adds to the charm." Expect lines at peak times and a tight, cozy space where standing is common unless you arrive early or luck into a table. The drinks lean classic with playful dessert twists rather than theatrics, delivering strong pours and neighborhood-favorite signatures like the Dirty Bird. When it is slammed, a few details can slip—garnishes missed, cream skipped on a dessert martini—but hit it off-peak and the cocktails shine with a steady hand. Families should note this is a bar-first environment: alcohol-focused, often loud, and geared to adults. There is no kids menu or food, and seating is limited; it suits date nights or pre-dinner rounds more than family outings.
At a Glance
- Cozy, stylish decor with festive seasonal touches
- Strong, well-loved martinis at fair neighborhood prices
- Lines and counter-ordering even from bar seats during peak times
- Drink consistency can slip when the bar is slammed
- Patio expands comfort and vibe in warm weather
What Sets It Apart
- deep_martini_list
- festive_seasonal_decor
- neighborhood_vibe
- strong_pours
What People Love
- Festive, cozy ambiance
- Signature Dirty Bird martini
- Friendly bartenders off-peak
- Strong pours that feel worth the price
- Neighborhood gem energy
Points of Concern
- Counter ordering and queues even for seated guests on busy nights; attentiveness feels reduced
- High volume and music can make conversation difficult at peak times
- Inconsistent prep and garnishes when rushed; better off-peak
- Review patterns show normal variance around reopening; minimal manipulation signals
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$20-35 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- If you prefer gin, start with Classic Dry Martini ($15) before exploring dessert options
- For savory fans, the Dirty Bird ($15) with blue cheese olives is a neighborhood favorite
- Sensitivity to sweetness: request lighter hand on liqueurs for dessert martinis
Perfect For
- Pre-dinner martinis before Andersonville dinner
- Date night with a lively vibe
- Girls night or small celebrations
- Out-of-town friends touring neighborhood bars
Location Insights
Area: Charming, LGBTQ-friendly Andersonville block with boutiques and independent venues; popular evening foot traffic.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, steady neighborhood presence; busy on weekends.
Nearby: Near Clark Street corridor shops, casual eateries, and other bars; residential streets nearby.
EdgewaterEdgewater is a lakeside neighborhood with a relaxed, community-oriented atmosphere. The dining scene includes a mix of casual eateries, bars, and ethnic restaurants, reflecting the area's diverse population. It is known for being accessible and family-friendly while also attracting a younger crowd looking for affordable and trendy spots.
AndersonvilleAndersonville is a distinct micro-neighborhood within Edgewater known for its strong Swedish heritage, independent shops, and a vibrant dining and nightlife scene. It has a welcoming, inclusive vibe with many locally owned bars and restaurants that emphasize craft cocktails and unique menus.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday17:00–02:00
Tuesday17:00–02:00
Wednesday17:00–02:00
Thursday17:00–02:00
Friday15:00–02:00
Saturday16:00–02:00
Sunday14:00–02:00
Available: Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →