Seemor
Hartley'sB+Worth Trying
14 Putnam Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
· Irish pub
· 4.8/5 Google (404 reviews)
Reservations · Takeout · Outdoor seating
A cozy Irish pub known for standout Guinness pours, friendly bartenders, and a small but satisfying comfort-food menu; arrive early as the intimate room fills fast.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Hartley's delivers solid neighborhood pub excellence through reliable Irish comfort food and exceptionally warm, knowledgeable bartenders that create genuine local appeal. The cozy, intimate setting and reputation for the city's best Guinness pour build loyal patronage, but tight seating that becomes crowded at peak hours and occasional kitchen delays when slammed prevent grade A territory. A genuine neighborhood institution worth visiting for authentic Irish hospitality and well-executed classics.
Restaurant Summary
Low-lit and intimate, Hartley’s plays the role of the neighborhood Irish pub with warm, chatty bartenders and a bar that locals treat like a living room. One guest summed it up: best Guinness in the city and a room that fills fast. Expect a cozy, buzzy vibe that can tip loud when the crowd swells. The cooking leans classic Irish comfort—stews, cheddar-forward toasties, and house soda bread—more elevated tradition than flashy fusion. Dishes pair naturally with pints; the stew and house-spiced beef sandwich draw steady praise, while a few note slower kitchen times at peak and a toastie that feels pricey for portion. Families do stop in, and there are familiar, kid-comfort foods like grilled cheese, potato wedges, and mash. That said, the room is small and can get crowded and loud during prime hours. Vegan options exist but are limited, so plan accordingly if you need more than a pint.
At a Glance
- Exceptionally well-poured Guinness and friendly bartenders
- Cozy neighborhood pub vibe with reliable Irish comfort food
- Very limited seating; gets crowded and loud at peak times
- Kitchen can be slow when slammed; some items feel pricey for size
- Occasional live music on Mondays adds character
What Sets It Apart
- exceptional_guinness_pours
- house_soda_bread_sandwiches
- intimate_neighborhood_pub_vibe
- occasional_live_music_mondays
What People Love
- That near-perfect Guinness pour
- Warm, personable bar team
- House soda bread with butter
- Hearty stew and brisket sandwich
- Authentic, candle-lit pub atmosphere
Points of Concern
- Small room with limited tables; standing or waits common at peak
- Loud music and crowd volume on busy nights
- Food wait times lengthen when packed (20-30 minutes reported)
- Vegan options are scarce; sauces may contain allergens
- Review patterns show signs of natural enthusiasm but not manipulation; still, high five-star share warrants mindful reading
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleHybrid
Average Cost$36-48 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- For vegetarians: Roasted Carrots & Parsnips ($14) plus Soda Bread & Butter ($10).
- For lighter bites: Popcorn with Irish Cheddar ($7) and Potato Wedges ($11).
- If you want a full plate: Irish Ham with mash ($26) or Guinness Stew ($23).
- Allergy note: Ask about sauces like curry mayo and relishes if sensitive.
Perfect For
- A relaxed pint and hearty snack
- Low-key date night in the neighborhood
- Catching up with a friend at the bar
- Solo stop for a quiet early-evening pint
Location Insights
Area: Leafy residential-clustered streets with creative professionals and students; relaxed neighborhood energy near brownstones.
Safety: Generally safe, well-traveled blocks and good lighting; late-night foot traffic typical of neighborhood bars.
Nearby: Near Pratt Institute, small shops, and other eateries; a local hangout rather than a destination strip.
Prospect HeightsProspect Heights is a culturally diverse and rapidly gentrifying neighborhood with a mix of historic brownstones and new developments. The dining scene is eclectic, featuring trendy cafes, upscale restaurants, and casual eateries, attracting a crowd interested in artisanal and international cuisine. The area is known for its proximity to Prospect Park and the Brooklyn Museum, contributing to a lively and community-oriented atmosphere.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday16:00–01:00
Tuesday16:00–01:00
Wednesday16:00–01:00
Thursday16:00–01:00
Friday16:00–03:00
Saturday12:00–03:00
Sunday12:00–01:00
Available: Reservations, Takeout, Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →