Seemor
Salty DogB+Worth Trying
7509 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209
· Bar & grill, American restaurant, Restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (1239 reviews)
Reservations · Delivery · Takeout
Lively Bay Ridge bar and grill with standout burgers, wings, and party-friendly space; service is often warm but can be inconsistent at peak times and parties.
Why it gets a B+ for overall quality
Salty Dog delivers solid neighborhood bar fare with strong food quality anchored by standout burgers and wings, supported by spacious, comfortable layout ideal for groups and game-day crowds. However, inconsistent execution in service timing and occasional food quality lapses prevent a higher grade—expect reliable comfort food and friendly regulars, but occasional service friction during peak times.
Restaurant Summary
The room feels warm and bustling, a big Bay Ridge bar where TVs glow, live bands pop up, and servers trade jokes with regulars. One diner summed it up: "Burgers were spot on and our server kept the laughs and refills coming." However, expect occasional slower greetings at peak and the typical game-day rush. The cooking skews classic and hearty rather than fussy: smash-style and signature burgers, jumbo wings with lots of sauces, shortrib shepherd pie, and crowd-pleasing wraps and pastas. It is comfort-first bar fare with a few lighter detours like a salmon wrap, ideal for watching a game or hosting a casual celebration. Families do fine here thanks to kid-friendly staples like chicken fingers, burgers, mac and cheese, and fries. If little ones prefer simple flavors, stick to tenders, plain burgers, or pasta. It is lively during sports, so earlier hours may suit younger kids best.
At a Glance
- Standout burgers and broad wing sauce lineup
- Spacious sports setup and party-friendly layout
- Strong neighborhood following and repeat regulars
- Service can be slow or dismissive at busy times and parties
- Isolated cleanliness and delivery disputes reported
What Sets It Apart
- large_sports_setup
- party_event_hosting
- neighborhood_regulars_scene
- broad_sauce_selection_for_wings
What People Love
- Juicy signature burgers with crispy fries
- Cold draft beers and lively game-day buzz
- Helpful event staff for showers and birthdays
- Neighborhood welcome with repeat-friendly vibe
Points of Concern
- Peak-time seating delays and greeting lapses reported by several groups
- Party gratuity and reservation communication caused friction for some hosts
- Occasional cocktail quality complaints and bar attitude reports
- Isolated roach and cleanliness mentions contrasted with many clean visits
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleTable Service
Average Cost$38-55 per person
ReservationsRecommended
What to Order
- Burgers: Salty Dog Standard or Lamb Burger for variety
- Wings: Choose classic Buffalo or try Inside Out Sauce
- Comfort mains: Shortrib Shepherd's Pie on cooler nights
- Lighter picks: Grilled Salmon Wrap or House Salad with chicken
Perfect For
- Watching big games with friends
- Casual burger-and-beer nights
- Hosting showers or birthdays
- Family dinners with picky eaters
Location Insights
Area: Residential Bay Ridge corridor with neighborhood bars, family eateries, and sports-watching spots; attracts locals and group gatherings.
Safety: Generally safe, well-trafficked avenue with evening activity; typical urban awareness advised.
Nearby: Third Avenue strip with pubs, restaurants, and shops; close to residential blocks and waterfront parks further west.
Bay RidgeThe dining scene in Bay Ridge is diverse, featuring a mix of traditional American, Mediterranean, and seafood restaurants. The area has a neighborhood-friendly atmosphere with many locally owned establishments, attracting both families and casual diners looking for relaxed, approachable dining experiences.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Tuesday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Wednesday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Thursday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Friday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Saturday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Sunday12:30–01:00, 11:30–00:00
Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →