Lively SoHo spot for New York and New Haven style pizzas, crowd-pleasing pastas, and a cult-favorite burger; excellent flavors, energetic vibe, but pricing is on the high side with occasional service inconsistencies.
Fini's delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional food quality—particularly standout thin-crust pizzas and house red sauce—paired with strong service attentiveness and chef engagement. The prime SoHo location and lively atmosphere make it competitive with the area's better neighborhood restaurants, though occasional consistency variations and premium pricing prevent it from reaching grade A territory.
Set on Elgin Street, this spot hums with SoHo energy where sidewalk tables make for prime people-watching. Staff are often warm and upbeat, and several diners mention the chef stopping by to explain specials. One guest summed it up: great food with a lively vibe, though pacing can feel brisk when dishes land fast. The cooking leans Italian-American with a New York and New Haven tilt—think thin, charred pies, a crowd-pleasing rigatoni, and a surprisingly beloved burger—executed with quality ingredients and a house red sauce that wins repeated praise. Creative accents like choy sum pesto and mala aioli keep it interesting without straying into theatrics, perfect for diners who want comfort with a modern edge. Families fare well here: pizzas feed 2–3, chicken parm is generous, and pastas please most palates. There is no formal kids menu noted, but classics like Margherita pizza, fries, and mac and cheese make it easy for younger diners; adventurous options are available if you want to nudge tastes a bit.
Area vibe: Buzzy SoHo lane with bars and casual-upscale eateries; strong expat and after-work crowd.
Safety: Well-trafficked nightlife zone; generally safe with busy evening footfall and good lighting.
What's nearby: Clustered among restaurants and bars on Elgin Street; popular for people-watching and pre/post-drinks.
Thin, charred New Haven-style pizzas and a well-executed Rigatoni Alla Vodka are the safest bets.
Casual dress is fine, peak service can feel brisk, and a 10% service charge applies.
Expect lively, people-watching street-side energy in a casual, inviting space.