Neighborhood spot for fresh, scratch-made pasta and thin-crust pizza with quick counter service; great flavors, some hygiene and consistency gaps to note.
Cibo Makarna and Pizza delivers solid food quality with well-executed fettuccine Alfredo and crisp thin-crust pizzas at fair neighborhood pricing, earning its reputation among local pasta enthusiasts. However, hygiene concerns including reported hair in pasta and dirty condiments, combined with inconsistent topping accuracy and sauce portions across visits, prevent a higher grade. The cramped mezzanine seating and moderate review authenticity patterns add to the assessment uncertainty, positioning this as a worthwhile neighborhood spot rather than a destination restaurant.
One caveat: Hygiene inconsistencies noted by several diners (dirty condiments, lack of hairnets)