Seemor

Olives Mediterranean Grill Key WestA-

730 Emma St, Key West, FL 33040 · Restaurant · Key West

Small, welcoming Turkish spot off Duval serving fresh mezze, kebabs, and standout baklava with warm owner-led hospitality; great flavors, tight seating, and portions-to-price debates.

Our take

Olives Mediterranean Grill delivers exceptional food quality anchored by standout mezze, Iskender, and pistachio baklava, paired with outstanding owner-led hospitality that creates genuine warmth. However, severe space constraints with tight seating and recent consistency dips on busy nights prevent grade A territory, while moderate review authenticity concerns add slight uncertainty to the assessment.

In more detail

Tucked off Duval, this tiny Turkish spot wins hearts with warm, owner-led hospitality, quick hot plates, and a relaxed neighborhood vibe. One diner said the room felt like a friend’s home, with the chef sharing stories and coffee tips. However, there are some review authenticity concerns - some review patterns are consistent with solicited or influenced feedback. The cooking leans classic Turkish mezze and grills rather than theatrics: fluffy hummus, smoky baba ghanoush, tender chicken shish, and an Iskender that locals and travelers rave about. The pistachio baklava is a frequent showstopper, and Turkish coffee makes a fitting finish. A few recent critics mention small portions or drier meats on busy nights, but most praise bright, fresh flavors. For families, it is surprisingly kid-friendly thanks to simple hits like chicken kebab, rice, fries, and pita with dips. No kids menu is noted, but plenty of approachable choices balance the more traditional plates; picky eaters can build a meal from mezze and wraps.

Standout dishes

What people love

Worth knowing

Location Insights

Area vibe: Quiet residential pocket of Old Town near Truman Annex; casual, local-leaning away from Duval bustle.

Safety: Generally safe Old Town zone with steady foot traffic; some reviews note nearby housing authority and confusing parking signage.

What's nearby: Walkable to Fort Zachary Taylor and Truman Waterfront; residential streets with limited curb parking.

Frequently asked

What should I order at Olives Mediterranean Grill Key West?

Iskender, hummus, and pistachio baklava are the must-tries, with mains generally priced in the high teens to high twenties.

What should I know before going to Olives Mediterranean Grill Key West?

It’s a casual, tiny neighborhood spot with limited parking and occasionally modest portion sizes for the price.

What's Olives Mediterranean Grill Key West like?

A warm, owner-run spot with authentic decor and a lively yet relaxed neighborhood energy.

Opening Hours

Sunday10:00–21:30 Monday10:00–21:30 Tuesday10:00–21:30 Wednesday10:00–21:30 Thursday10:00–21:30 Friday10:00–21:30 Saturday10:00–21:30
See full Restaurant DNA analysis — grade reasoning, occasion fit, what to order & more →