Outdoor seating
Classic Italian spot with a lively, familial vibe and generous portions, but food quality and service consistency are hit-or-miss for the price.
Anacapri delivers a charming, family-run Italian experience with warm and attentive service and notably efficient pacing, but inconsistent food quality and variable execution prevent a stronger grade. The appealing central location and outdoor seating enhance the convivial atmosphere, yet the restaurant falls short of the area's premier dining destinations due to unpredictable dish quality and limited menu scope.
Anacapri is a classic Italian eatery tucked just off Baker Street, where the family-run warmth and lively, bustling vibe are as much a part of the experience as the food itself. Diners are greeted with genuine hospitality—think olives and bread on arrival, a friendly owner making the rounds, and a terrace that fills with laughter on sunny days. The menu leans heavily on traditional Italian comfort food, with generous portions and a dessert trolley that’s become something of a local legend. Culinarily, Anacapri sticks to the tried-and-true: expect familiar pasta, steak, and fish dishes, with little in the way of modern twists or fusion. This is a place for those who crave old-school Italian flavors and a convivial, energetic setting. While some regulars rave about the authenticity and return year after year, others find the food inconsistent—carbonara, for example, is either a highlight or a letdown depending on who you ask. The absence of pizza and garlic bread on the current menu has surprised more than a few guests, so don’t come expecting the full pizzeria experience. For families, Anacapri offers a welcoming atmosphere and large portions, but the menu may not thrill picky eaters—especially kids who expect pizza or simple fare. While tortellini and gnocchi are mentioned as hits with younger diners, the lack of classic kid options means adventurous eaters will fare best. If your little ones are happy with pasta and dessert, you’ll likely leave satisfied; otherwise, you may want to check the menu in advance.
Area: Bustling, cosmopolitan area near Baker Street and Marylebone, popular with both locals and tourists; lively, urban, and walkable.
Safety: Generally safe, well-lit, and busy with steady foot traffic; typical for central London.
Nearby: Surrounded by shops, cafes, and offices; close to Baker Street station, Madame Tussauds, and Regent's Park.
Available: Outdoor seating
View full analysis on Seemor →