Lively, old-school Italian in Pimlico with hearty pasta and pizza, warm service most nights, and good value, though service consistency and shellfish safety have recent red flags.
O'Sole Mio delivers reliable neighborhood Italian dining with strong food quality in pasta and pizza and genuine, attentive service that keeps regulars returning. However, inconsistent execution—including recent shellfish handling issues and occasional service lapses near closing—prevents it from reaching higher territory. The pleasant Pimlico setting and good value make it competitive with respected local favorites, though it lacks the distinction of premier dining destinations.
One caveat: Recent shellfish complaints (off mussels) suggest caution with frutti di mare dishes