Seemor

Pizza Pilgrims Covent GardenA-Worth Trying

Name: Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden
Address: 23 Garrick St, London WC2E 9BN, London, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.5

23 Garrick St, London WC2E 9BN · Neapolitan restaurant, Gluten-free restaurant, Halal restaurant · 4.5/5 Google (4166 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden delivers standout Neapolitan pizzas in a lively setting, but expect premium prices and occasional service hiccups.

Why it gets an A- for overall quality

Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden delivers exceptional Neapolitan pizza quality with creative toppings and reliable dough execution, anchored by an outstanding central London location that makes it ideal for pre-theatre dining. However, occasional quality variation and service inconsistency during busy periods prevent it from reaching grade A territory, while high pricing limits its appeal as a casual neighborhood favorite.

Restaurant Summary

Pizza Pilgrims Covent Garden is a lively, central London spot serving up Neapolitan-style pizzas that have won over both locals and tourists. The dough is consistently praised for its chewy, airy texture, and the menu features both classic favorites and creative twists—think Double Pepperoni & Hot Honey or a vegan Margherita. The atmosphere is fun and informal, with playful decor and a buzz that makes it perfect for a pre-theatre bite or a casual night out. Service is generally friendly and knowledgeable, though it can be stretched thin during peak hours, leading to occasional slowdowns or missed requests. The culinary approach here leans contemporary Neapolitan, blending tradition with inventive toppings and dietary inclusivity. Vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free diners are well-catered for, and staff are happy to guide you to the right choice. While the food quality is reliably high, value perceptions are mixed—some find the prices fair for the location and quality, while others balk at bills that can reach £50 for two with drinks and service charge. Portion sizes are generally satisfying, but a few diners wish for more generous pies. For families: The menu offers plenty of approachable pizzas that most kids will enjoy, but the service and facilities are less accommodating for young children. Several reviews mention staff being flustered by buggies or not providing baby-friendly amenities. If you're dining with older kids or teens, you'll likely have a smooth experience, but parents with infants or toddlers may find it less welcoming. The food itself is kid-friendly, but the overall family experience is just adequate.

At a Glance

Standout Neapolitan pizza with creative and classic options.
Excellent location for pre-theatre or Covent Garden outings.
Vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free pizzas available.
Service can be slow or inattentive during busy times.
Prices are high for casual pizza—expect £25+ per person for a full meal.

What Sets It Apart

creative_pizza_specials
central_covent_garden_location
vegan_and_gluten_free_options

What People Love

The chewy, flavorful pizza dough and fresh toppings
Creative specials like Double Pepperoni & Hot Honey
Friendly staff who offer great menu recommendations
Fun, lively vibe that feels authentically Italian
Dietary inclusivity—vegan and gluten-free options that don't compromise on taste

Points of Concern

Service can be inconsistent, especially during peak hours—some diners report slow or inattentive staff.
Prices are high for casual pizza, with bills for two easily reaching £50 including drinks and service charge.
Space is tight and seating can feel cramped, particularly downstairs.
Families with young children may find the service and facilities less accommodating than expected.

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£22-28 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Try the Double Pepperoni & Hot Honey or Smoky Aubergine Parmigiana for something unique.
Vegan and gluten-free diners can confidently order pizza here.
Desserts like the Nutella Pizza Ring are popular for sharing.

Perfect For

A quick, delicious meal before a West End show
Pizza lovers seeking both classic and inventive toppings
Groups of friends looking for a lively, casual dinner
Vegan, vegetarian, or gluten-free diners wanting real options

Location Insights

Area: Bustling, tourist-friendly area with a lively, casual vibe. Covent Garden attracts a mix of theatre-goers, shoppers, and families.

Safety: Generally very safe, well-lit, and busy at most hours. High foot traffic and strong police presence.

Nearby: Surrounded by theatres, shops, and other restaurants. Close to Covent Garden Market and major West End attractions.

Covent GardenA bustling neighborhood with a rich artistic heritage, featuring numerous restaurants, boutique shops, street performers, and proximity to major cultural venues. The dining scene is eclectic, ranging from historic pubs to contemporary international cuisine.

Seven DialsA charming sub-area characterized by its distinctive seven-way street intersection, featuring independent boutiques, artisan cafes, and a sophisticated dining environment.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:30–22:30 Tuesday11:30–22:30 Wednesday11:30–22:30 Thursday11:30–22:30 Friday11:30–23:00 Saturday11:30–23:00 Sunday12:00–21:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →