Lively Soho pizzeria serving reliably tasty Neapolitan-style pies with standout gluten-free options, strong hospitality, and fair prices, though service can wobble at peak times.
Pizza Pilgrims Soho delivers solid neighborhood dining with excellent food quality—particularly the signature double pepperoni with hot honey and reliable Neapolitan technique—and warm, attentive service that staff like Jemima and Luigi execute with genuine care. However, inconsistent execution with occasional burnt or undercooked pies, combined with cramped space comfort and service slowdowns at peak times, prevents grade A territory. It's a well-run casual pizzeria that exceeds typical neighborhood standards without reaching destination status.
One caveat: Occasional misfires on doneness (burnt or undercooked) reported by a minority