Seemor

Reverend J W SimpsonB+Worth Trying

Name: Reverend J W Simpson
Address: 32 Goodge St, London W1T 2QJ, London, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.5

32 Goodge St, London W1T 2QJ · Cocktail bar · 4.5/5 Google (349 reviews)

Reservations

Inventive, conversation-friendly speakeasy with expert, bespoke cocktails and occasional service friction; best for craft drink lovers who value creativity over volume pours.

Why it gets a B+ for overall quality

Reverend J W Simpson delivers expertly crafted cocktails and exceptional spirits knowledge that justify its loyal following, but inconsistent execution and occasional service friction during busy periods prevent a higher grade. The intimate speakeasy aesthetic suits its date-night positioning, though solo-bartender waits and cramped seating create friction that outweighs the charm for some guests.

Restaurant Summary

Down a Fitzrovia staircase, the room feels warm and intimate, all shabby-chic walls and soft music where conversation comes easy. Regulars rave about the owner-bartender’s depth of knowledge: "He nailed my preferences and told the drink’s story." A few recent nights saw service friction when the bar got busy, but most visits describe thoughtful hospitality and a calm, date-night pace. The cocktails lean contemporary and technique-driven—clarified milk, foams, mezcal and Danish whisky all make appearances—so expect inventive flavor combos rather than comfort classics. It suits guests who enjoy guidance and are happy to linger over 2–3 crafted rounds. If you prefer big pours over nuance, you may find the large-ice presentation a touch precious for the price. This is an adult-focused cocktail den, not a family venue. There is no kids’ menu and the experience centers on bespoke alcoholic drinks. If bringing a group, book and arrive early; otherwise, come as a couple or solo at the bar for the best guidance and pacing.

At a Glance

Bespoke cocktails tailored to your palate
Conversation-friendly speakeasy vibe
Deep spirits knowledge from the owner
Service can falter during peak times
Pricey for smaller-format serves

What Sets It Apart

bespoke_cocktail_consultation
subterranean_speakeasy_ambience
clarified_milk_program

What People Love

Personalized recommendations that feel spot on
Creative serves like clarified milk and citrus foams
Quiet music and cozy, subterranean setting
Feeling of a hidden gem worth seeking out

Points of Concern

Occasional reports of rude or confrontational management on busy nights
Long waits when only one bartender is working
Perception of small pours due to large ice and spirit-forward builds
Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£30-36 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

If you like bright and sparkling, try Soixante-Quinze (£15).
If you enjoy agave and spice, Pomala (£15) with tajin rim hits sweet-sour-salty notes.
Coffee lovers: Café Culture (£14.50) blends whisky with cold brew.

Perfect For

Date night before or after dinner on Charlotte Street
Solo cocktail nerds seeking conversation with the bartender
Small groups wanting a quiet, creative round
Pre-theatre drinks near the West End

Location Insights

Area: Creative Fitzrovia side street with media offices and boutique shops; draws cocktail seekers and date-night crowds.

Safety: Generally safe, well-lit West End environment with steady foot traffic into late evening.

Nearby: Near Goodge Street station, Charlotte Street restaurants, and Oxford Street shopping.

FitzroviaFitzrovia offers a dynamic dining scene with a mix of trendy cafes, traditional pubs, and upscale restaurants. The social atmosphere is lively yet somewhat relaxed compared to neighboring Soho, making it popular for both casual meals and after-work gatherings.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday Tuesday17:00–23:30 Wednesday17:00–23:30 Thursday17:00–23:30 Friday17:00–00:30 Saturday17:00–00:30 Sunday

Available: Reservations

View full analysis on Seemor →