Seemor

Ristorante OlivelliA-Worth Trying

Name: Ristorante Olivelli
Address: 9 St Christopher's Pl, London W1U 1NE, London, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.3

9 St Christopher's Pl, London W1U 1NE · Italian restaurant, Sicilian restaurant · 4.3/5 Google (609 reviews)

Reservations · Delivery · Takeout · Outdoor seating

A lively, authentic Italian spot in Marylebone offering generous portions and classic dishes, but expect premium prices and occasional service inconsistencies.

Why it gets an A- for overall quality

Ristorante Olivelli delivers solid A-grade performance through strong food quality anchored by authentic Italian classics and exceptional location appeal in prime Marylebone. However, inconsistent execution across visits and cramped seating conditions prevent the higher distinction needed for grade A territory, while premium pricing reflects the prime location rather than exceptional value.

Restaurant Summary

Ristorante Olivelli brings a slice of Sicily to the heart of Marylebone, offering authentic Italian flavors in a lively, bustling setting just steps from Oxford Street. The menu is a celebration of classic Italian comfort food—think creamy carbonara, truffle-laced tagliolini, and generous antipasti—served in portions that leave few diners hungry. The location is a major draw, with outdoor seating perfect for people-watching and escaping the city’s chaos. While the atmosphere is warm and inviting, be prepared for close quarters and a bit of a squeeze during busy times. The culinary approach here is traditional with a few creative flourishes, making it a haven for those who crave familiar Italian favorites with the occasional modern twist. Signature dishes like the truffle pasta and tortelloni paradiso earn rave reviews, and the pizza is a reliable crowd-pleaser. This is not the spot for avant-garde dining, but rather for those who appreciate well-executed classics and a convivial vibe. Expect prices to reflect the prime location and quality ingredients—most diners spend £40-50 per person for a full meal with wine. For families: Olivelli is generally kid-friendly, with staff praised for accommodating children and offering approachable dishes like pizza and pasta. However, space is tight, and there are isolated complaints about stroller/baby buggy policies. The menu includes several vegetarian and some gluten-free options, but vegan choices are not clearly labeled. If your kids are adventurous eaters, they’ll be happy here; picky eaters may want to stick to the classics.

At a Glance

Generous portions and authentic Italian flavors.
Prime Marylebone location with outdoor seating.
Premium pricing—expect £40+ per person for a full meal.
Tight seating and occasional service inconsistencies.
12.5% service charge automatically added to bill.

What Sets It Apart

central_marylebone_location
authentic_sicilian_menu
generous_portions
outdoor_seating

What People Love

The truffle pasta and tortelloni paradiso are crowd favorites
Friendly, attentive staff who remember regulars
The charming, hidden-away location in St Christopher’s Place
Portions that satisfy even the hungriest diners
A warm, welcoming vibe that feels authentically Italian

Points of Concern

Some diners find the prices high for the portion and quality, especially with the automatic service charge.
Space is limited—tables are close together and the restaurant can feel cramped at peak times.
Service can be inconsistent, with occasional reports of slow or inattentive staff.
Isolated complaints about stroller/baby buggy policies and handling of service charge disputes.

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleTable Service Average Cost£38-48 per person ReservationsRecommended

What to Order

Try the truffle pasta or tortelloni for a signature experience.
Vegetarians have several options, including antipasti and risotto.
Seafood lovers should consider the Scoglio or Granchio e Brandy pastas.
Ask staff about vegan options if needed, as menu labeling is unclear.

Perfect For

A lively dinner with friends after shopping on Oxford Street
Family gatherings where everyone loves Italian food
Date nights in a charming, central London setting
Celebrating special occasions with classic comfort food

Location Insights

Area: Bustling, upscale pedestrian area popular with shoppers and professionals; lively yet relaxed vibe.

Safety: Very safe, well-lit, high foot traffic, and well-maintained.

Nearby: Located in St Christopher’s Place near Oxford Street, surrounded by boutiques, cafes, and other restaurants; close to Selfridges and major shopping.

MaryleboneA refined, cosmopolitan neighborhood featuring elegant boutiques, gourmet restaurants, and a sophisticated urban atmosphere with a mix of historic charm and contemporary style.

St Christopher's PlaceA charming pedestrian-only enclave with boutique shopping, European-style outdoor dining, and a sophisticated, intimate urban village atmosphere nestled between Oxford Street and Marylebone.

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday11:30–22:00 Tuesday11:30–22:00 Wednesday11:30–22:00 Thursday11:30–22:00 Friday11:30–22:00 Saturday11:30–22:00 Sunday11:30–22:00

Available: Reservations, Delivery, Takeout, Outdoor seating

View full analysis on Seemor →