Excellent Neapolitan pizzas with friendly, quick table service at moderate prices; expect occasional service hiccups and variable delivery quality.
Santa Maria Pizzeria Islington delivers excellent Neapolitan pizza with authentic dough and quality toppings at moderate prices, earning strong loyalty among regulars. However, inconsistent execution during peak hours and delivery service prevents a higher grade—undercooked or burnt pizzas and service delays appear frequently enough to be a genuine concern. The convenient Upper Street location with warm, bustling atmosphere makes it a solid neighborhood favorite, though not a destination restaurant.
One caveat: Service delays and occasional missed items when the restaurant is very busy (mentioned by multiple diners)