Characterful Hammersmith pub with sports, pool, darts and friendly staff; hot pies and decent drink deals shine, but cleanliness and occasional service lapses are recurring weak points.
The Old City Arms delivers solid neighborhood pub quality with genuinely warm, welcoming staff and reliable pies at fair prices, but inconsistent execution—occasional sold-outs and off-days— and a lived-in rather than polished setting keep it from higher territory. Strong local loyalty and riverside location make it a worthwhile casual stop for sports, pints, and comfort food, though not a citywide destination.
One caveat: Some reports of sticky tables and grubby feel during busy times