Lively Neapolitan-style pizzeria with standout pies, arancini, and tiramisu at fair prices; service is friendly but occasional slow or inconsistent nights happen.
Theo's delivers solid neighborhood dining through strong food quality—particularly standout tiramisu and reliable Napoli salami—paired with friendly, responsive service and fair pricing. However, inconsistent execution on busy nights, with reports of undercooked or soggy bases, prevents grade A territory. The warm, bustling setting with urban views appeals to locals and theater-goers, but walk-in waits and modest space comfort keep it a solid neighborhood favorite rather than a destination.
One caveat: Occasional long waits and orders slipping during rush hours