Seemor

Yard Sale PizzaBWorth Trying

Name: Yard Sale Pizza
Address: 39 Lordship Ln, London SE22 8EW, London, United Kingdom
Rating: 4.7

39 Lordship Ln, London SE22 8EW · Restaurant, Italian restaurant, Pizza Takeout · 4.7/5 Google (236 reviews)

Delivery · Takeout

Creative New York-meets-London pizza with standout specials and friendly counter service; great flavor, fair value, but delivery timing and vegan options can be hit or miss.

Why it gets a B for overall quality

Yard Sale Pizza delivers excellent food quality with creative New York-style pizzas and standout service attentiveness that earns strong local loyalty. However, inconsistent execution during peak delivery times and limited seating prevent grade A territory—this is a reliable neighborhood favorite rather than a destination pizzeria, best enjoyed via pickup or off-peak dine-in.

Restaurant Summary

This East Dulwich slice shop feels warm and neighborly from the moment you walk in, with staff who remember faces and nudge you toward the right half-and-half. Reviewers describe pizza that is "hot, crispy, and full of flavor" and a crew that will even rescue a misaddressed delivery on the fly. The cooking leans creative New York style with London flair: think hot honey pepperoni, NY-style Margherita with provolone, and buzzy collaborations like Dishoom that diners rave about. The culinary approach leans contemporary and topping-driven: playful combinations and limited editions rather than strict Italian orthodoxy. Most regulars praise the dough and balance, though a small minority report the occasional undercooked or cold pie, especially via delivery at peak times. Families do fine here thanks to simple crowd-pleasers like Margherita and pepperoni, plus the option to go half-and-half. Seating is limited, so dine-in with kids is easier off-peak, while delivery and pickup are the norm. Vegan options exist, but feedback is mixed on flavor and melt, so manage expectations for plant-based choices.

At a Glance

Creative specials and collaborations that taste great
Friendly, proactive staff with strong local following
Delivery can arrive late or cold at busy times
Vegan pizzas receive mixed feedback on flavor
Creative/fusion menu - not traditional comfort food

What Sets It Apart

limited_time_collaborations
extra_large_18_inch_option
house_dough_for_home_use

What People Love

Lively team that goes the extra mile
Playful toppings like hot honey pepperoni
Reliable dough and crust texture
Fast turnaround for pickup and delivery
Neighborhood vibe on Lordship Lane

Points of Concern

Delivery timing and temperature can slip at peak hours; pickup is more reliable
Vegan options draw mixed reactions on flavor and melt
Limited seating means dine-in comfort is modest
Review patterns show signs of potential manipulation (staff name repetition, templated responses, clustered enthusiasm) which may not reflect typical diner experience

Service & Dining Experience

Service StyleCounter With Seating Average Cost£20-28 per person ReservationsNot required

What to Order

Try a half-and-half to sample a special alongside a classic
Pair a Margherita with garlic bread for a balanced meal
Choose 12 inch for solo, 18 inch for sharing; add dips for variety

Perfect For

Casual weeknight takeout
Sharing a giant 18 inch pie with friends
Trying limited-time collaboration pizzas
Family pizza night with easy pickup

Location Insights

Area: Leafy, residential South London high street with independent shops and family traffic; casual neighborhood vibe.

Safety: Generally safe and well-frequented in evenings with steady foot traffic.

Nearby: Close to other casual eateries and shops on Lordship Lane; popular for takeaway and deliveries to nearby homes.

East DulwichA trendy and gentrified area with a mix of independent cafes, boutique shops, and local restaurants. The neighborhood offers a sophisticated yet relaxed dining and lifestyle scene with strong community character

Practical Information

Opening Hours

Monday16:00–22:00 Tuesday16:00–22:00 Wednesday16:00–22:00 Thursday16:00–22:00 Friday12:00–22:30 Saturday12:00–22:30 Sunday12:00–22:00

Available: Delivery, Takeout

View full analysis on Seemor →