A small, lively Mexican spot with standout margaritas, mezcal selection, and tacos al pastor; excellent flavors but portions run small and prices feel high to some.
Mexcalista delivers solid A-grade performance through exceptional food quality anchored by authentic tacos al pastor and enchiladas, paired with attentive, personable service and a standout mezcal and tequila program. The reliable execution and charming literary quarter location support its reputation as a neighborhood favorite, though modest portions and premium cocktail pricing prevent it from reaching grade A territory, and the intimate space requires advance booking for preferred seating.
Tucked into the literary quarter, this room feels warm and bustling with a serious agave bar and modern, comfy decor. Service skews personal—several guests mention the owner checking in—and cocktails shine. One diner summed it up: best margaritas of the trip, with tacos to match. The cooking leans authentic Mexican over fusion—trompo al pastor, enchiladas verdes and seafood staples like aguachile and ceviche. Flavors are bright and precise, though plates run modest in size and cocktails carry a premium. Expect a cocktail-forward experience with a curated mezcal list rather than a bottomless-plate taqueria. Families will do fine here thanks to kid-pleasing tacos and quesadillas. The menu includes vegetarian choices (guacamole, nopales, tamales veg), but vegan options are limited despite one review’s expectations—plan accordingly. Portions are on the smaller side, so order an extra plate if sharing with kids.
Area vibe: Historic literary quarter with artsy bars and boutique restaurants; attracts cultured locals and travelers.
Safety: Generally safe, well-patrolled, busy in evenings with good lighting and foot traffic.
What's nearby: Steps from Prado/Cortes area, theaters, and galleries; strong pre- and post-theater dining scene.
Tacos al Pastor and enchiladas are reliable bets, with ceviche or aguachile if you want seafood and margaritas or mezcal cocktails to match.
It is a casual but compact spot that fills up quickly, portions run small and cocktails cost more than at a typical taqueria.
A warm, buzzy room centered on a curated mezcal and tequila bar with modern, comfortable decor.