Polished resort seafood spot with beautiful sunset setting, creative preparations, and attentive service at its best, but with real inconsistency in pacing, temperature, and value; great for occasions if you accept resort pricing and variability.
Nick's Fishmarket delivers solid resort dining with exceptional setting appeal—the sunset lanai and garden views create a genuinely memorable backdrop for special occasions. Food quality shines with creative seafood preparations and a celebrated rack of lamb, supported by attentive service and strong wine knowledge. However, inconsistent execution across visits—temperature lapses, variable pacing, and occasional small portions—prevents the higher tier; this is reliable special-occasion dining rather than destination-caliber consistency, and resort pricing demands flawless delivery.
One caveat: Service pace varies widely; several reports of 45-90 minute waits between courses