Reliable, generous-portioned Italian-American and New York-style pizza near Haleakala; great for hearty meals, with occasional service and consistency hiccups.
Serpico's delivers reliable comfort dining with strong food quality anchored by crisp New York-style pizza and generous portions, plus genuinely welcoming service that makes the experience feel personal. Occasional consistency lapses—dry crust, cold takeout, missing items—and a simple, modest dining room prevent it from reaching higher territory, though it remains a solid neighborhood favorite and convenient Haleakala-area stop worth visiting.
One caveat: Sporadic execution misses: a few reports of very hard crust or cold, soggy takeout