Creative Modern Indian with standout service and memorable small plates; excellent set menus but pricing and portion size spark debate—go for inventive flavors, not old-school curry house value.
ISH delivers inventive modern Indian cooking with strong food quality highlighted by standout paneer, chaat, and roti duck tacos, paired with genuinely attentive service that makes diners feel welcomed. However, inconsistent execution—including lukewarm mains and variable spice balance—combined with peak-night pacing delays prevents the restaurant from reaching grade A territory. The pleasant Gertrude Street setting and loyal following suggest a solid neighborhood favorite, but execution reliability needs strengthening for higher distinction.
On Gertrude Street, ISH feels warm and polished without the stuffiness. Servers are genuinely attentive and help steer you through a creative menu. One diner summed it up: "We left feeling looked after, from welcome to cocktails." Delays can happen on peak nights, but most visits hum along comfortably. The cooking leans modern and fusion-forward—think roti duck tacos, bright chaat, and house-made paneer in silky gravies. It suits diners who enjoy inventive spins more than strict tradition. Portions trend refined rather than hearty, so the set menus often deliver the best arc and value for the experience. Families are welcome, but the menu tilts adventurous. Kids who enjoy butter chicken and naan will be fine; picky eaters may struggle with bolder flavors and smaller portions. There is no clear kids menu, so build a meal from simpler curries, rice, and breads.
Area vibe: Trendy inner-north strip with boutiques, galleries, and bars; draws diners seeking creative, upscale casual experiences.
Safety: Generally safe, lively foot traffic in evenings; well-lit commercial corridor.
What's nearby: Gertrude Street dining corridor near Smith and Brunswick Streets; bars, cafes, and galleries nearby.