A casual seafood-market restaurant with notably fresh seafood, strong chowders and fried classics, but recent drain-fly reports and occasional inconsistency warrant checking current conditions before dining in.
Anthony's Seafood delivers strong food quality anchored by fresh, well-cooked fried seafood and standout chowders that keep regulars returning. Service moves efficiently in its counter-service model, and pricing rewards generous portions. However, visit-to-visit inconsistency in execution and a modest, utilitarian setting prevent a higher grade, making this a reliable casual stop rather than a destination.
Anthony’s Seafood is a casual seafood-market stop on Aquidneck Avenue, outside Newport’s busiest restaurant core. The rhythm is simple and efficient: browse the market, order at the counter, then settle into a booth or patio while a tray of food arrives. Regulars and visitors alike describe a relaxed, unpretentious place where “the seafood tastes like it came straight from the market,” though the room can feel tight when busy. The cooking is rooted in classic New England seafood rather than fine-dining theatrics. Fresh shellfish, hot lobster rolls, fried clams, fish and chips, Rhode Island chowder and especially Portuguese fish chowder are the main attractions, with a few modern touches such as Kung Pao calamari and salmon tacos. Most diners find the food fresh, generous and fairly priced, but execution can vary: some report greasy frying or disappointing chowder, and recent visits raised a recurring drain-fly concern that management says it is addressing. Families are well served by the menu’s practical fallback options: chicken tenders, burgers, hot dogs, grilled cheese, mac and cheese and fries sit alongside the seafood. Reviews also describe accommodating family groups, outdoor seating and dog-friendly patio visits. This is a good choice for children who want familiar food, though parents should consider outdoor seating or confirm that the reported fly issue has been resolved before dining in.
Area vibe: Historic seaside region with a strong boating and tourist economy.
Safety: Generally safe, quiet suburban streets with decent lighting; seasonal busier summers.
What's nearby: Near Aquidneck Island towns, marinas, local shops, and short drive to Newport attractions.