Seemor
A Slice of New YorkB-Worth Trying
2407 Nicollet Ave, Minneapolis, MN 55404
· Pizza restaurant
· 4.4/5 Google (1067 reviews)
Delivery · Takeout
Solid New York-style slices and calzones at fair prices with quick counter service; dine-in quality strong but delivery consistency and cleanliness reports are uneven.
Why it gets a B- for overall quality
A Slice of New York delivers authentic New York-style pizza with strong food quality and friendly, attentive service, earning its solid neighborhood reputation. However, inconsistent execution between dine-in and delivery, combined with isolated but serious cleanliness concerns, prevents a higher grade. Best experienced as a casual slice stop for straightforward, satisfying pizza rather than a destination dining experience.
Restaurant Summary
Walk in to a compact slice joint that feels warm and bustling, with pies on display and a steady flow at the counter. Staff interactions are often friendly and upbeat, and several diners highlight crisp, foldable slices with herby sauce. One regular summed it up: "This is where I go when I crave a proper New York slice." The cooking sticks to classic comfort pizza more than chef-driven experimentation. You will find big slices, hearty calzones, and a few Greek-leaning specials like gyro pizza rather than culinary theatrics. Dine-in slices tend to shine; whole pies and delivery draw mixed consistency notes, so expectations should lean toward a straightforward, satisfying slice experience. Families do well here thanks to simple crowd-pleasers: cheese or pepperoni slices, spaghetti, and milder pies fit most kids. There is no dedicated kids menu, but portions are generous and prices reasonable. Adventurous eaters can branch into Buffalo chicken or gyro options, while picky eaters can keep it simple without stress.
At a Glance
- Crunchy, foldable NY-style slices with flavorful sauce
- Fair prices and generous portions, especially by the slice
- Delivery quality and timeliness are inconsistent
- Occasional cleanliness and pest complaints from isolated reviews
- Limited parking; metered curbside only on busy corridor
What Sets It Apart
- true_slice_counter_experience
- large_foldable_slices
- Greek-influenced specialty pies
What People Love
- Big, foldable slices that hit the NY nostalgia button
- Friendly counter staff who keep things easy
- Good value for the size of pies and calzones
- Straightforward menu with reliable classics
Points of Concern
- Delivery orders vary in quality; dine-in slices are more consistent
- Parking can be tight and metered near the shop
- A few reviews cite cleanliness or pests; most do not mention issues
- Review patterns show normal variance with some heated negatives
Service & Dining Experience
Service StyleCounter With Seating
Average Cost$18-28 per person
ReservationsNot required
What to Order
- Pair a $4.99 slice with a $7.99 salad for a balanced light meal
- Share a $23.99 specialty pie and add a $4.99 cannoli to keep checks moderate
Perfect For
- Quick solo slice before or after events
- Casual group meetup on Eat Street
- Late-night comfort food stop
- Family pizza night without a splurge
Location Insights
Area: Bustling Eat Street corridor with diverse eateries, student and young professional traffic, casual vibe.
Safety: Generally busy and fine with typical urban caution at night; active foot traffic.
Nearby: Near other casual restaurants, cafes, and small shops; convenient to downtown and medical mile.
Uptown MinneapolisThe dining scene in Uptown is diverse, featuring everything from casual eateries and coffee shops to upscale restaurants and bars. The atmosphere is energetic and social, often bustling with people looking for nightlife and contemporary dining experiences. It is considered safe and highly accessible, with a strong emphasis on walkability and public transit.
Nicollet Avenue CorridorThis stretch along Nicollet Avenue is known for its concentration of popular restaurants, bars, and cafes, making it a hotspot for social gatherings and culinary exploration. It has a youthful, hip vibe with a mix of longtime residents and newcomers.
Practical Information
Opening Hours
Monday11:00–23:00
Tuesday11:00–23:00
Wednesday11:00–23:00
Thursday11:00–23:00
Friday11:00–00:00
Saturday11:00–00:00
Sunday
Available: Delivery, Takeout
View full analysis on Seemor →